Fate/stay night - WHAT IF we really have a Holy Grail War?

He's a hero simply because he's awesome.

Also Hondam Tadakatsu

Would Sherlock Holmes count as a spirit hero? And if he does, under what class would he be considered? Cause I can only see him as a caster.

Most likely Caster. I don't think he can go as any other class. Or rather he will never be able to go any other class LOL.

He will most likely have a lot of investigation skills and skills that help him understand the opponents abilities.

Truthfully, the ultimate natural enemy of Jack the ripper........Looks like I have to kill you 1st Aeiro. D:

Spirit: Yamamoto Isoroku (Rider)
Master: -
N. Phantasm: A++
Strength: C
Agility: B
Mana: B
Luck: D
Endurance: C

Class skills:

Magic Resistance: C
Riding: A+

Personal skills:

Bravery: A
Charisma: C
Military Tactics: B

Noble Phantasms:

Yamato Class Battleship: Yamato & Musashi A++

the heaviest and most powerfully armed battleships ever constructed,displacing 72,800 tonnes at full load and armed with nine 46 cm (18.1 inch) main guns. Designed to counter the numerically superior battleship fleet of the United States during the World War 2.

I think you mean Yamamoto not Yamato.....

Thanks didn't notice

up rep.

HUHUHU!!! I shall accept your challenge!!!

Hmm. Any one person, as anyone class... That's a difficult decision....


I'd have to go with Genghis Khan as either Berserker, or Rider, but preferably Rider.

There's gonna be a real Holy Grail War on FAKKU soon... and I'm gonna take all the servants made here to add to the huge list of servants I'm making soon...

Please, for the love of you, PLEASE DON'T leave me out of it!

*grovels on the ground*

Loooooool.

Well, other people are yet to show interest on it for me to invite them personally. Let's see how things goes for now.

Well, when the time comes, invite me too. I'll join as well

Do ho ho.

It's actaully an RP in case you haven't realized. ;)

Main requirement to join is having the determination to stick and not abandon the game though. (No one's gonna ask you to be an awesome writer.)

More info: https://www.fakku.net/viewtopic.php?t=76795&start=60#2604746

And I'll try to not to derail the topic here anymore (post there instead of here is my point).

Actually, if you really think about it, Sherlock can go to the Assassin class.
(I'm a big fan of the book and have been reading it over and over again since I was a kid.) Why?

1. He was known for really realistic and superb disguises.
2. His acting skills are... let's just say A+ to A++.
3. He has above average physical condition.
4. Knows martial arts and a formidable bare-knuckle fighter (boxing without gloves and more brutal rules) that Watson even commented "he was undoubtedly one of the finest boxers of his weight that I have ever seen."

Now combine all of that and add some 3 ounces of literary steroids and (drum-roll), you might get a Sherlock Assassin.

If someone comes to you stating that Sherlock doesn't want to kill. Just go with the story that Sherlock once had a thought of how he is as a criminal. Now this is just his perfect chance, a Holy Grail War.

It was actually the Nameless One who gave me the idea, someone who's literally immortal and has lived "countless lifes" and "played" the role of all known walks of life and tragedy. The Wandering Jew could be someone who lived such a life.

His sole ambition in "life" is his own demise, to finally achieve rest. He can only be summoned by using a nail from Pilate's door - as he was a doorman - and his summoning is an irregular event, since he's not a Heroic Spirit.

Class Name: Avenger
True Name: Joseph of Arimathea/The Wandering Jew
Sex: Male
Alignment: True Neutral

Strength: D
Mana: E
Endurance: C
Luck: F
Agility: D
Noble Phantasm: EX

Class Skills :
Brooding & Angsting. (Comes with the territory of being a sucky Servant with very quirky qualities).

Personal Skills:
Despite his fairly bad stats, Josehp is actually a very dangerous opponent. During his unending wandering he's learnt pretty much all skills and lore known to men, as he's lived various identities, peddling in varios professions. An adept of all, master of known... if not for his noble phantasm he'd be hard pressed to even challenge Servants, with it even his "average" skills can lead to surprising results.

Noble Phantasm:
Cursed to Wander the Earth - Sustaining Curse of the Savior (EX++) - Personal.

Ever since he mocked the Savior, Joseph literally can't die, cursed to eternally wander the Earth. He can be dismembered, beheaded, torn asunder, but eventually he always comes back to life. Even the immense power of other Noble Phanstams can't overcome this curse.

2 words, Rule Breaker. There's your solution.

I'll have Phoenix Wright as my servant and his noble phantasm would be "Objection!"

Real historical figures only my friend.

By the gods, that's one hell of a servant you have. Freakin cool. What will happepn to the master and the command spell when he died and havent ressurrected yet?



My Servant : Assassin
Class Name:
True Name: Ken Arok
Sex: Male
Alignment: Neutral Evil

Ken Arok was the founder and first ruler of the Singhasari Kingdom, an ancient Hindu-Budhist kingdom in the East Java area of Indonesia. He was considered as the founder of Rajasa dynasty of both the Singhasari and Majapahit line of monarchs. He came from humble origins but subsequently rose to be the most powerful ruler in Java. His life was coloured with adventures, treacheries, and tragedies.

Strength: B
Mana: B
Endurance: C
Luck: D+
Agility: A
Noble Phantasm: B

Class Skills :
Presence Concealment A+: It is possible to disappear completely and become almost impossible to be detected. However, efficacy will decrease once preparations to attack are taken.

Personal Skills:
Divinity : C
According to the legend, Ken Arok is son of the god Brahma having an affair with a woman called Ken Ndok.

Expert Of Many Specializations B
Ability to use a wide array of skills with great prowess. At this rank, astronomy, navigation, cartography, academics, rhetoric, tactics, diplomacy and a number of others making up a total of 18 skills may be used with proficiency of rank C or above.


Mind's Eye : B
A sixth sense of avoiding danger. In Ken Arok's case, he gained this ability through his life in the slum where he needs to be wary all the times.


Noble Phantasm:
Mpu Gandring - Cursed Kris of 7 Kills
A supernatural kris named after the smith who makes it, Mpu Gandring. Within it contains evil spirits which crafted together with the kris, making the kris a dangerous weapon of curse. This kris also contains the spirit of Mpu Gandring which
killed by Ken Arok using this Kris. Anyone cut by this kris will be cursed and killed seven times despite the wound size, regardless of any ressurection skills or physical endurance. If the enemy has no resssurection means, he/she will be killed once. This ability came from the legend where Mpu Gandring, just before he died, cursed the kris to take the life of Ken Arok and 6 of his descendant.


Wanting to make Indonesian servant. I choose Assassin since I can't think of another Class befitting him. If some info or fact doesn't match, please do tell me.

I've actually thought of this before, so here's mine. As a caveat, I imagine them as a woman instead of a man, think Aisha from Koihime Muso...and if I'm not aloud to do that, then I'll think a little more cause I'd like a female servant :3

Class Name: Rider
True Name: Kan'u Unchou (Guan Yu)
Sex: Female
Alignment: Lawful Neutral

Guan Yu was one of the Tiger Generals of Shu during the Three Kingdoms period of China. Known for her illustroius black hair, Guan Yu was a warrior of great pride and honor. Famed for her heroics as Si Shui Gate, Guan Yu eventually gave up her ideals to save her lord Liu Bei and entered the service fo Cao Cao of Wei. Guan Yu remained in Cao Cao's employ for a time before returning to Liu Bei's side to uphold the Peach Garden Oath that she, Liu Bei, and Zhang Fei had made so long ago. While fighting Wei to help Shu unify the land, Guan Yu was defeated by her own rebelling troops and a surprise attack by Wu. After her death, she became a regional chinese god of war and economics.

Strength: B
Mana: C
Endurance: B
Luck: D
Agility: B
Noble Phantasm: C/B+/EX

Class Skills :
Mind's Eye (Fake): C
Independant Action: C
Bravery: B
Charisma: C

Noble Phantasm:
Green Dragon Blade (C): The naginata (or so it is popularly depicted) of Guan Yu that is forever linked with her name.

Red Hare (B+): The greatest of Chinese war horses. Originally belonging to Lu Bu, but later gifted to Guan Yu by Cao Cao after Lu Bu's death. It's grade is reduced because Guan Yu is not the original owner.

Flood of Fan Castle (Ex): Basing this off the more popularized version of Guan Yu's death, Guan Yu used a flood attack to wear out and defeat the Wei forces at Fan Castle. Upon moving in to secure the castle, she was betrayed by her own soldiers and forces which had moved behind her from Wu. The very waters which had been used to gain victory equally caused her defeat, as she was trapped in the castle. This attack, only usable near an open source of water, imprisons the foe in a supersonic water cage, allowing her to use her great skills to defeat the trapped foe. This takes a heavy toll on her mana however, and is not a skill that can be used more than once or twice in succession.