I like Hanako the best because shes alot like me :3. The only difference between us is that I dont have any burn scars. Despite her being a fictional character, shes the only person I can really relate to :).
I just started playing yesterday myself and went straight for my weakspot, Hanako. Getting her good ending was well worth it, and the story tore me apart. Next I'll probably go over Lilly or Emi. I don't care for Rin much. Katawa Shoujo was just right for my first vn.
Lilly is my favorite, her route was my favorite and I especially liked the art direction in her path. Emi's route was really fun though too so she's a close second. And yeah, I'm like 93% complete or something and only bad ends remain so I'd say I've beaten it.
Mines would be Hanako because I wanna EMBRACE HER and tell her everything is gonna be alright, but it's a little too short. Lilly's arc seems complete. :D <3
I would like to point out to those ranting about not being able to vote for Misha that...Shiina is her "real" name, and she is listed as such in the poll.