Another rep idea
0
I dunno if this is a good idea or too complicated. I think it might be neat if you could give partial rep(like in 0.1 increments). People would still have a daily limit of 1 rep point worth of change to give or take, but could divide it among different people or give/take a smaller amount of rep for smaller things. Because it is still out of a total 1 point per day, the value of rep wouldn't change.
For example, say person A(who has 3 rep) does something kinda nice and B(who has 3 rep) does something kinda mean. C could +.5 to A giving him 3.5 total and -.5 to B for a total of 2.5. Between the two, C has spent all his rep giving/taking ability for the day.
I figure it might also be cool if different ranks could give/take a higher total per day. Maybe at the minimum post requirement they can give/take 1 (or maybe .5 or something) per day. Each rank up they can give/take slightly more per day, like .1 added to their daily give/take capacity.
This whole system would require the +/- buttons being replaced with something like a drop down menu or box to type it in.
So, what do you guys think? Does this sound good to everyone?
Jacob, what about you? What do you think about the suggestion? If you do like the idea, does it sound doable or would such a change be a pain in the ass to make?
For example, say person A(who has 3 rep) does something kinda nice and B(who has 3 rep) does something kinda mean. C could +.5 to A giving him 3.5 total and -.5 to B for a total of 2.5. Between the two, C has spent all his rep giving/taking ability for the day.
I figure it might also be cool if different ranks could give/take a higher total per day. Maybe at the minimum post requirement they can give/take 1 (or maybe .5 or something) per day. Each rank up they can give/take slightly more per day, like .1 added to their daily give/take capacity.
This whole system would require the +/- buttons being replaced with something like a drop down menu or box to type it in.
So, what do you guys think? Does this sound good to everyone?
Jacob, what about you? What do you think about the suggestion? If you do like the idea, does it sound doable or would such a change be a pain in the ass to make?
0
i think thats too hard :(
but the idea is good though :wink:
oh what about if you created a topic at user upload section, you get automatic +rep for uploading your stuff...just an idea though and i know its still full with flaws :roll:
but the idea is good though :wink:
oh what about if you created a topic at user upload section, you get automatic +rep for uploading your stuff...just an idea though and i know its still full with flaws :roll:
0
Hmm, I think the auto +rep thing would encourage people to upload crappy stuff or spam the board with single uploads instead of just putting multiple in one post or topic.
I don't think it would be too complicated, just a drop down menu with 1 to -1 listed in .1 increments. At least it wouldn't be complicated for the people using it. As for Jacob to make it, I have no idea what kind of work that would require, maybe a lot maybe not (I know nothing about the process of making sites).
I don't think it would be too complicated, just a drop down menu with 1 to -1 listed in .1 increments. At least it wouldn't be complicated for the people using it. As for Jacob to make it, I have no idea what kind of work that would require, maybe a lot maybe not (I know nothing about the process of making sites).
0
Just turn the reputation system into a decimal variable, take the persons rep / 10, and that's how much it should affect the user.
10 rep would give out -1/+1, 20 rep would give out -2/+2... very simple!
ADDED: It should store the last person you -'d. If you try to - that person twice, it hits yourself instead.
Or use Lurking's idea. But something really ought to be done.
10 rep would give out -1/+1, 20 rep would give out -2/+2... very simple!
ADDED: It should store the last person you -'d. If you try to - that person twice, it hits yourself instead.
Or use Lurking's idea. But something really ought to be done.
