[Locked] Is "fake loli" a good choice for a new FAKKU tag?

Alright, so I noticed that the people behind FAKKU have been asking if there are any new tags that would be good to add, but personally I would say that this is a big one, just due to how relevant it is in the FAKKU doujins.

Fake loli is more or less as it sounds. It's where female characters have a smaller stature than that of an ordinary female, making them appear underage(kind of like a loli). However, they are presented as someone who is of legal age, and thus is known as being a "fake loli". Examples of certain characters that fall under this category are Taiga from Toradora, Konata from Lucky Star, Louise from Zero no Tsukaima, etc.

So this poll is more to ask the viewer base whether they would prefer to have this tag or not.

Pettanko is probably meant to cover that.

They can, but basically a pettanko is any woman with a chest size below a C cup. So think of it as being more proportional to their bodies. They also have a complex/insecurity over the size of their chest. I am 22 but I am a pettanko.

Loli is any person younger then 12 or before puberty in some cases. They can be considered pettanko since most are flat chested, but you will see some content that is considered loli (age-wise) yet they have big boobs and are very developed (usually the scenario where they are young and physically went though puberty really early).

OT: I don't disapprove, rather I don't really see the point of a "fake loli" tag myself. Pettanko and if fakku were to ever get a loli tag in general would suffice.

With fakku books, this site may not need adverts anymore as Jacob will get money from that.

and without any 3rd advert company, it should mean loli can be unbanned as it was the advert company that didn't want loli

You mean will be unbanned right?

That's how I look at it and I am assuming that this is what the general course of action will be. I am not against loli myself, I just break it down for people when they don't understand why it isn't on here, but eventually if they start to sell it which they stated they will then we might see more genre's pop up that were once banned on here.

yeah

Pettanko does the job.

I don't see it happening. Loli is a grey area in the United States and just to keep advertisers happy, it isn't allowed. An occasional loli doujin slips in every once in a while but by putting "fake loli," you might as well as look at pettanko or make an actual loli tag.

I get that Pettanko does a good job with all that, but it's not necessarily the same as what I'm speaking of. Pettanko can be characters of any height and body size. Fake loli is intended more along the lines of being shorter or smaller. In my eyes there's a distinct difference.
For example, this would be an example of pettanko but not fake loli:
https://www.fakku.net/manga/harem-butai-wa-boku-wo-shaburi-tsukusu-ch-4/read#page=12
and this would be an example of fake loli:
https://www.fakku.net/doujinshi/tsukaima-yapu-tristain-no-metsubou-japanese/read#page=12
The reason I ask for this is more or less because I've found it on other sites as a search option and it helped out what I was looking for moreso than just "small breasts/Pettanko"

Okay, cool story bro. Do you want an Ahoge tag too? Fakku already has very limited tags so these very specific ones like the one you're suggesting should be considered after all major tags have been implemented like watersports or maybe lactation. If you want to customize a manga search to the smallest minutiae, go to hbrowse.

Lactation and watersports are actually not bad idea's for tag's on here. As for the "fake loli" tag, the issue with this is two things.

1) loli is still not something that they can allow on here at this time, though this could change
2) you have to use your personal judgement as to what would be considered pettanko, loli, or fake loli. Which I doubt would happen.

I look at Louise as a pettanko and a tsundere. She isn't a loli given her age and she is sometimes drawn in a more loli-ish fashion, but this is up to interpretation by various artists who draw her. I think it's just easier to keep it the way it is and just use other site's if you need something more specific that this site can't offer.

Dear god nevermind, clearly no one gets it.
Fake loli is NOT ACTUAL LOLI, HENCE THE "FAKE" IN THE NAME. Fake loli are characters that LOOK under age, maybe even preteen, but are LEGAL AGE despite their appearances. The criteria for this tag is EXTREMELY common, more-so than "watersports" ever will be. I'm not making shit up here either, this is an actual tag that other sites use, and it works well.

You don't have to bold text things for people to see your point you know? You've made it, we understand it, people have responded. That's all there is to it.

Even though some of us don't agree with the tag we don't think it's a terrible idea or that you are bullshitting. I know for me personally I just think it's pointless when there can't even be a tag to contraindicate the fake part of that tag and other tag's suffice on here for people's needs. Besides, to me fake loli is just pettanko with a youthful appearance or a loli that isn't a true loli because the age is different (is a loli though because of the body, but it's just some author's way of getting past the whole loli ideology). If the tag get's added then kudo's to you, if not then no skin off of anyone's back.

Okay, you're not some victim. We get what you're saying. But, as Misaki Chi said, a problem with this kind of tag is that often it's up to the artist's and tagger's discretion. Look up Louise no Tsukaima by Type Moon; in that Louise most definitely is pettanko. Also, the criteria for watersports is pretty cut-and-dry. If anything, it's this fake loli thing that has hard to clarify criteria.



I'm calling bullshit. What sites are you getting this tag from? I went to exhentai, one of the biggest hentai sites out there and there's no "fake loli" tag. At least when I looked at some Tora Dora and Lucky Star doujins. I went to lu.scio.us and nothing there. I also looked at hbrowse, which has the most specific of tags I've ever seen anywhere. No "fake loli" there either. It's not even a tag on gelbooru.

Loli isn't just actual age, but perceived age. You can be 20 and look underage. You could be underage and look of age. There many example of this. Plus fake loli is won't be considered because loli is in it. Just DFC is sufficient. There a big business in 3d legal loli in japan.

It's not like Fakku is even trying to ban lolis anymore... what's the issue again?

@Misaki_Chi thanks for responding so calmly despite my stupid exclamations. I'm new here (easy to tell by number of posts I guess), but you were right in that I'm overreacting a little. Personally I just thought it was an easily applied tag, but I guess people are fine with the Pettanko tag alone. I swore I saw it on Lu.scio.us, but 623 said he looked there and couldn't find it, so in retrospect I don't know where the hell I found it...
Oh well, guess that's it then. Sorry for my stupid rants and thanks for the feedback.

Didn't read the former discussion but.. isn't it a dead giveaway and would give rise to suspicion as if it's written "this is not rape"?

Too much of a dead give away if you ask me, like others have said.