this has probably been suggested before.
0
But I feel it needs to be said again.
Fakku needs a rating system. Something like a star system. 1-5 or 1-10 or something like that.
I have kind of high standards for hentai manga. (Odd I know, but it's true.) And so I don't like wasting time reading a manga that doesn't thrill me.
An attractive group of tags is really all I have to judge a manga by with out actually reading it. So I rating system would monumentally helpful.
Just my three and a half cents.
Fakku needs a rating system. Something like a star system. 1-5 or 1-10 or something like that.
I have kind of high standards for hentai manga. (Odd I know, but it's true.) And so I don't like wasting time reading a manga that doesn't thrill me.
An attractive group of tags is really all I have to judge a manga by with out actually reading it. So I rating system would monumentally helpful.
Just my three and a half cents.
3
PatchyMcScarlet
Spandau Ballet
The comments are usually my rating system ^^
I do feel however it would be impractical to apply to something like this where people would maliciously give things that aren't of their interest a bad rating without reading it simply for the content they know is within; a problem persistent in NTR/Forced works where people moan about the fact it's.. NTR/Forced.
I do feel however it would be impractical to apply to something like this where people would maliciously give things that aren't of their interest a bad rating without reading it simply for the content they know is within; a problem persistent in NTR/Forced works where people moan about the fact it's.. NTR/Forced.
0
Patchy is right it wouldn't work, its bad enough people get rep bombed for saying something one way or another, imagine what would happen with a rating system with a hot topic like NTR/Vanilla.
Its just not worth the trouble IMO
To much work too little to gain. As it will be abused not used.
Its just not worth the trouble IMO
To much work too little to gain. As it will be abused not used.
0
artcellrox
The Grey Knight :y
PatchyMcScarlet wrote...
I do feel however it would be impractical to apply to something like this where people would maliciously give things that aren't of their interest a bad rating without reading it simply for the content they know is within; a problem persistent in NTR/Forced works where people moan about the fact it's.. NTR/Forced.This, so fucking much. Fakku is a hive for vanilla idiots who don't know how to read the tags to avoid what they don't like. Hentai fans in general are a fickle public. Hell, even in ExHentai, some really good doujins (in terms of art and story, in my opinion) get completely neg bombed simply because they're a tag that people don't like, such as yaoi and pegging.
Yes, this has been suggested before, and the answer is still no.
0
Gravity cat
the adequately amused
PatchyMcScarlet wrote...
I do feel however it would be impractical to apply to something like this where people would maliciously give things that aren't of their interest a bad rating without reading it simply for the content they know is within; a problem persistent in NTR/Forced works where people moan about the fact it's.. NTR/Forced.This.
I can't see such a rating system being 100% used for judging the quality of the content within, which would result in the ratings being misleading.
0
Misaki_Chi
Fakku Nurse
Siding with people on saying no to a rating system. I've seen other hentai sites have it and even though it has some use, the amount of abuse and mi-use is pretty evident in works. I think the comment system on here suffices as an indicator on how the work will be when you read it or just look at sections such as most popular/most controversial and whatnot.
I'm usually one that I want to read it to judge for myself rather then go off of a rating I see.
I'm usually one that I want to read it to judge for myself rather then go off of a rating I see.
1
6 or 7 years ago we had a 5 star rating system, I killed it because I felt it was gimmicky and unnecessary. It leads to the more niche fetishes getting poor ratings because the majority of people don't like it.
0
The funny thing is, if you examine ratings on e-hentai, NTR/forced material consistently gets higher ratings than vanilla. Why? Because the people who are not interested in vanilla gang up to sabotage the ratings on vanilla galleries, while the people who dislike NTR/forced stuff generally have the commonsense to ignore that stuff, despite being a much larger group.
It's possible the result would be different for Fakku! if a rating system were implemented, but I'm skeptical about that.
It's possible the result would be different for Fakku! if a rating system were implemented, but I'm skeptical about that.
0
Gravity cat
the adequately amused
freudia wrote...
The funny thing is, if you examine ratings on e-hentai, NTR/forced material consistently gets higher ratings than vanilla. Why? Because the people who are not interested in vanilla gang up to sabotage the ratings on vanilla galleries, while the people who dislike NTR/forced stuff generally have the commonsense to ignore that stuff, despite being a much larger group.It's possible the result would be different for Fakku! if a rating system were implemented, but I'm skeptical about that.
If anything, you just confirmed why ratings would be a bad idea via another site that has the feature.
0
I honestly hadn't considered people misusing it. That seems so rediculous to me, but perhaps that's because I'm a reasonably accepting person. I just ignore and avoid the tags I dont like.
Never stopped to consider that people might give bad ratings just because of an unattractive tag, but I suppose that does make sense.
A few idiots ruining it for everyone.
Never stopped to consider that people might give bad ratings just because of an unattractive tag, but I suppose that does make sense.
A few idiots ruining it for everyone.
0
thisisausername wrote...
I honestly hadn't considered people misusing it. That seems so rediculous to me, but perhaps that's because I'm a reasonably accepting person. I just ignore and avoid the tags I dont like. Never stopped to consider that people might give bad ratings just because of an unattractive tag, but I suppose that does make sense.
A few idiots ruining it for everyone.
Even if it wasn't misused, I still don't think it would be a very good idea. It's very likely that you don't agree on any of the top rated comics because how subjective it is, ya know. Well for now you have 'most favorites' which serves the same purpose. 'Most rated' is only based on the numbers of comments, iirc.
Well if you need any help finding high quality comics then I would suggest you to follow a few artists you like.
