We need a foot fetish tag

Probably because "foot fetish" is very ambiguous, even on other sites apart from Fakku.

https://www.fakku.net/tags/ashikoki

Also
>most popular fetish
That's debatable.

Problem is most hentai that relates to foot fetishes end up with the person being stimulated by said feet and getting off by it hence the ashikoki tag. I'd say no to it personally. Also one of my least favorite tags since I find feet gross myself.

Still it would be a good thing to have a foot fetish tag cause people like you who don't like feet can stay away from them. These are 2 examples where it doesn't lead to ashikoki The shoe salesman's vice and Dear Secrets


Read full post

Implying I didn't.

Edit: Do we even have enough manga with non-ashikoki footplay to warrant a foot fetish related tag?

yea and i dont see how that would be a problem cause we have the animated, forced and loli tags

Forced was a staple to the site before we went legit. Loli was banned for a while but remained popular and once it was unbanned we had a fair amount uploaded before we went legit. We had an animated manga but since it's gotten removed, I don't see the point in that tag anymore.

Two examples isn't enough. In the past we've needed at least 10 before it was up for discussion. The problem is that it's a very specific tag (non-footjob footplay) and most of the hentai involving footplay is a footjob. Maybe in the future when we have more mangoes, but right now it seems kinda pointless unless you can provide more examples.

What you said didn't make sense. Fakku may be renovating their works, but there will be a decent number of forced and loli content again. Animated was created due to a very unique work that involved animation as part of its reading experience so the tag was created in essence of that.

Only two works does not constitute the creation of a tag, but if more works were to appear in the future then the tag could be up for discussion. Otherwise probably a no go for now.

Also just because I don't like the fetish doesn't mean I avoid reading them? I said least favorite, nothing about disliking nor avoiding. Only reason I said gross is because I personally find feet dirty, no disrespect for those that love what they love, we all have our fetishes. I never turn down reading hentai.

Jacob said if you can find 10+ mangas with a content for a tag he will consider a new tag in general in the past. Still doesn't automatically happen. Plus the lack of non licensed content won't help now.

One of the works you posted focuses on feet smell/worship, and the other one is just a two-page foot licking. You aren't being specific on what you want, do you want the "foot fetish" to include everything related to feet? Or want to separate it? Or maybe only works who focus on feet (like brother Pierrot's works)? Foot licking? Foot worship (sometimes associated with femdom)?

anything doing with feet should go to the feet fetish tag and we should get rid of the ashikoki tag

No. Foot worship is more of a personal fetish and getting someone off with a footjob is more sexual; they are different things. Merge those and suddenly it's more difficult to find the one people specifically prefer. It would make more sense to keep them seperate.

Then it will be very difficult for people who want to read only ashikoki. That's why I said earlier that a "foot fetish" tag is very ambiguous.
You'd need to separate tags for foot-related works. That's why I mentioned other possibilities.

Probably won't happen, the one thing I did discuss with Jake a while back when I started helping w/ tag editing was he doesn't want to have the site cluttered with a million tags like other sites do. Atm fakku has around 84 genre related tags, which is a fraction to what other sites have, but it is done this way to keep from over cluttering works with tons of tags.

Basically it comes down to quality versus quantity. You can make a point and say some tags aren't necessary, but ultimately it is not my choice on what tags are on here and what tags are not, just my two cents on the matter.

Foot-job is more common on the hentai genre list in relation to foot licking (over 100+ pages works versus 5 pages on exhentai). Foot worship isn't even really a genre for hentai when you search for it.

Well there's a lot of foot worship on the boorus. (Yeah yeah I know the boorus don't count) And there is also a fair amount of foot play/worship without genitals involved in some works out there. A site like this can't take "quality over quantity" at heart, much less if the future plans involve getting more works from publishers that have works that aren't so normal fetishes-related. See this user alone just means that there will be more people asking for specific tags/fetishes and the site won't be able to offer them, at least not in the best possible way.
But in the end the owner of the site has the last word anyway.

Last part is the take home msg, I just throw in my two cents because it's something I feel like doing lol. People can agree, disagree, argue, etc. Idc, that's the point of a forum, but I just have the view of no myself, can think of other more priority tags myself.

I do the same, go figure. But if we start thinking or talking about things with more priority here it would take us more than just one night.

lol that img and yup takes us as a community to help out with things (^^)b

And when it comes to the owner, as said earlier, you need to make it less vague, and then find 10 examples minimum, and that's your starting place.
Just saying 'foot fetish' and it being as broad as you stated would end up with it on virtually everything, which is pointless. All of the tags are quite specific. So, realistically, if you want another tag added, you're going to have to find something specific, and make it something people would want to search for. Like, foot jobs is very specific, and that caters to foot fetish people. You'll have to narrow what you're after quite a lot if you want it to be considered, and then find a few examples, as per the old style of tags suggestions.

Again, foot fetish, and what you described is just far too vague, and then makes it a lot harder for those who want to find foot jobs, if you remove that and blanket it in with other things.