Good Hentai Going BAD/Wrong: What's Your Opinion/Response?

Basically this is where I and you and they and we go to talk about when great hentais go bad and how we cope with it.

Example: "Tachibana's Circumstances with a man" is a 56 page goliath of harem porn by the artist "Jin". Jin is considered to be a really good artist by many, including me, but he loves NTR in the worst way. Not normal NTR, either. The kind of NTR that starts out like Vanilla and makes you get attached to a character before they get horribly raped. It's debateable how rapey the ending of "Tachibana's Circumstances" is (it's very) but there's a general agreement that it's fucking awful.

In response to Jin slapping my balls like that, here's a simple edit I made to cut the manga in half and keep the tone as well as the theme established in the beginning consistent:

It's not amazing, but it's better than the alternative. On the upside, the characters you kind of give a crap about are in a nice harem. On the downside you don't get to see them getting fucked stupid and creampied. Take it or leave it, editing manga is how I can download even the worst of porn and keep on fapping with a free conscious.

This isn't just about Jin's stuff, though. There's also Finecraft69, who is an amazing artist but an absolute troll (see recent upload) to his fapping fans.
Finecraft: "Oh, you like huge tits? How about glasses? You don't want a rape? Okay, I'll finally give you that. But in return you have to deal with a SENILE OLD MAN! MWAHAHAHAHA~!!"
*commence the eye-rape*

Anyway, since editing in "better" endings and such has been a pass time of mine, I thought I'd make a thread where the other Fakkuzas could talk about how they cope with the topic of Good Hentai Going Bad/Wrong and what they think.

You can upload your own edits if you want, but this is primarily a discussion thread.

...Also no, I couldn't edit out the old man from the latest Finecraft69 manga. I tried, though. I tried making him just a fat, balding guy, but his face is in EVERY FUCKING PAGE!! Too much work for too little result.
Fuck you, too, Finecraft69. I'll go back (as usual) to Motchie Kingdom's art instead, even if your girls are smokin'.

It adds to variety.
If every story ended with no conflict or always the same way, then it'll all just get boring too quickly.

Also, editing endings are just disrespectful of the authors who made them. Just really disrespectful. They worked on that, especially the Tachibana original story. MTSP had put almost 1 year's work into that while almost missing the deadline for the second part (completely missed the first deadline), so I find just rewriting it pretty bad.

The going conclusion here is if you can't handle it, don't read it.

[color=red]First of all, rep for mentioning Tachibana. Can't believe I missed that gem.
Opinion about Good H going Bad, I think that's normal. We've seen Bad H going Good (Touhou doujinshi, Avion Village) so why not?

Also editing ending/rewrite is bad idea. No matter how "bad" the story, we must respect the mangaka for finishing his work. Unless you want make a "alternative doujinshi" with your own drawing, if you really want happy end.

Feels so sad and funny when you see some comments like "We should burn the author's house now" after reading NTR stories.

If you "mentally" wounded after reading it, just change your pace with reading some light / vanilla h-manga to forget it. Simple.

Because in the end, its just a fiction. If you can't take the heat, then don't play with fire.

OOT : I have to admit, after reading stories like Rec and Tachibana, some part inside of me died. But I can't help my boner, that's why I'm started to "accept" NTR months ago. It was harder than "accepting" rape, but my dick is pleased.

These kinds of stories adds variety. As I always say "A Good NTR is when you think it's going to be Vanilla, and a Good Vanilla is when you think it's going to be NTR."
And honestly there can't be NTR if there's nothing to corrupt. The more good goes corrupt the better the NTR is.

About editing, I'm a huge no to rewrites for said reasons above my post. Mainly for the "No respect". If you want a good ending, make one for yourself, not rewrite existing works for your own convenience. Show people that you cna make "something better" with your own hard work.

Same as any Neutral guy would say, If you don't like it don't read it. I don't like Scat and guro, but I don't go around forcing myself to read one just because it has good illustrations. That's like eating something that will cause your allergies to wreck havoc just because it looks good, it's more destructive than productive.

Dear God...how did you guys recover after reading Tachibana-san's Circumstances With a Man?

I couldn't help reading it because the drawings were so damn good. BUT, it was extremely painful. Whenever I think of it or am reminded of it, I get really upset - to the point where my day is ruined T.T

Well, there's gonna be another chapter according to MTSP's blog...and I think it's going to get worse: http://karen.saiin.net/~mitosupa/nicky/nicky.html

I know I shouldn't read it, but somehow, I have the feeling it's going to end up on my computer eventually...

If a manga makes me emotional, then it did its job. Thats all I can say.

Because I don't let it "Damage" me. Don't take it seriously and let your dick do the talking.

Quite honestly Tachibana-san's Circumstances With a Man is in my top 3 favorite doujins of all doujins I've ever read. I've been DYING for a continuation to the second. Maybe like a "What happened when they willingly went to their room?", that would be great!

lol Kai dat phrase

Well I do felt little "damage" back then (Tachibana & Rec case), but the NTR part is really, really hot. Much more awesome than the first story. I really hope for MTSP release at c83 soon.

Just reminder : " You rage, you lose. "

I guess this is what it all come down to, huh? You guys are right. I've fapped to Tachibana-san's Circumstances With a Man countless times (hell, even yesterday!). It's just hard sometimes, not to empathize with the main character. But, I do look forward to the new release...!

The art was good. Besides, the main thing is to never, NEVER, never ever identify with the characters that are about to get fucked over. The moment that happens, you won't feel as bad.