WAIFU GAME XI: Discussion

If I may throw in my two cents about the claim...

From my understanding, you, Zandorf, are making the argument that the set is not complete because the 'F/SN Heroine Set' should contain Rider (and possibly other characters). Here is why I, as well as a few other people, think your reasoning is invalid.

In the Visual Novel, there are three routes. Fate, Unlimited Blade Works, and Heaven's Feel. The MAIN heroine of each route are Saber, Rin, and Sakura respectively. Now whether or not Rider, as well as other characters like Ilya, can be considered Heroines, is up to your opinion. However the MAIN heroines in the visual novel are only Saber, Rin, and Sakura. This is emphasized by the fact that Rider doesn't have an H-scene in the visual novel (or at least I'm pretty sure).

Although if you want even more of a headache deciding on what to allow PumpJack, I think I may have a flaw that might render this entire argument useless. Sabers Praetor's original claim of being part of the complete 'Saber Set' might be wrong. No one has claimed Sakura Saber which could be technically part of the set since the 'Saber Set' is so vague in the first place. No one has claimed Saber of 'Black' or Gawain yet either, but I assume that's because this is the '(Female) Saber Set'.

--------------

Also I have a question about the 6th slot rule. If there is a set cast of lets say four characters, and I claim two of them, whereas the other two characters are claimed by other users, can I still benefit from the 6th slot rule? In the rules it states that you are not able to complete a set by yourself, but if you claim more than one character, or even the majority, of the set by yourself does it still count as long as there is at least one other user who helped make the set?

I'll allow a maximum of half the set. So if the set requires 4, one person may claim up to 2. If it's a set of 10, I'll allow a maximum of 5.

How do we know if we've got a set? For example, I've got Asuka, if someone else claims Rei Ayanami, is that a set? (Female EVA pilots set, maybe?)

Jury: You Lot

Judge: Le Monsieur Moi & Me

I figured characters from the current season would go relatively quick, aside from the usual favorites. Sorry, I'll treat her right. ^^



Ugh, that's a toughie. Technically, it would, if we're referring to original TV & movies but you'd also need Mari if we refer to the new movies... @_@

Sets can be expanded upon.

So- for this particular example- only Asuka and Rei are required for the bonus- but someone else can jump in with Mari to get it, also.

And- if someone divorces- only the person who did a divorce would lose their bonus.


On a completely different note- this video has boosted Ran and Yuugi quite significantly in my approval ratings.



Besides the obvious, I also like that the voices actually match the characters. And- believe or not- I was initially attracted to the quality of the models and animation.

And dem fluffy tails.

Good.

Now tell me why that is.

Just might want to add the source. >.<



I see, so having sets can be pretty darned flexible (and potentially open to interpretation, though it makes sense in current example).

EDIT: @PumpJack: In case it hasn't been said yet, thanks for running this game.

According to the wiki page Sakura Saber is intended as a joke, we don't even know her true identity, basically her importance is as relevant as the shit stain on the back of my shoe.

Even without Mordred, Arturia and Nero still fill a set on their own methinks:
-One's a King the other one's an Emperor, making them both "Rulers".
-Arturia and Nero are considered the only two main Sabers from the whole franchise.
-Blue and Red

-
"look at those fickle peasants questioning our magnificence"

So hot.



If the set does become invalid, I can back it up with another one: Parent Saber (Arturia), and Child Saber of red (Mordred). "Father and son" in other words.

On a completely different matter, claiming Miyako and Momoyo would complete the majikoi heroine set. Or Momoyo alone would complete the Kawakami sisters set, for those who may be interrested.

You forgot to add what show/series she's from.

the sets are getting out of control

Sakura Saber is a parody character though I wouldnt really count that one but it is in Koha which is buyable so its debatable. And yes its a female set obviously which is why Gawain and Siegfried are excluded. Also Rider had a 2 image Sex Scene but it was in Shirou's 'dream'

@zan: Doesent matter who I quote you still got the message.

I don't remember this

>mfw my set is 7 people large...

It's totally there.

Probably cause she appeared as Tohsaka's body not her own it was pretty early on in one of the routes but when the dream Tohsaka opens her eyes you see Riders Pupils.

http://typemoon.wikia.com/wiki/Breaker_Gorgon
^read the last paragraph

Ah right.

Ha! That makes me eligible. Since I have Yukiko and someone claimed Chie. That makes up two of the four girls from the Seekers of the Truth female members.

Actually, Fuck. That makes a shit ton of people eligible. Are you sure about this Jack?

Read my original post, he's saying that you, personally, can claim up to half the set that you are attempting to be eligible for. So if you had Chie and Yukiko and the other two girls were already claimed, then you can get the 6th slot.

Livin' la vida loca

Man, I Was busy so i skimmed through the rules. I just hope no-one took my first claim...

-Reposted, so hopefully this makes me qualified.