Waifu Game 4 Chat Thread
0
luinthoron wrote...
Ryouma Sakamoto wrote...
Hentanize wrote...
Just a question about this rule. How about Saber? Isn't her full name Arthuria Pendragon? Does that mean in the next game people cant claim her by just stating Saber? The same goes for Rider, Caster and some other FSN characters.
Implying she's gonna be claimable in the next game?
> :lol: <
On a more serious matter, i'm against full names if they're gonna spoil people. That's pretty stupid if you ask me.
Last reset we got to keep 3, the later 2, now 1 so yes I am implying that she might be claimable if waar decides a whole wipe out in the next game.
In the case of Saber since there's only one saber being Arthuria Pendragon it's okay. But for the case of Rider and Caster it's different since Fate/Zero Riders and Casters are men. If someone claims Rider and someone claims Rider Medusa the Gorgon I feel that the second should be more legitimate since Rider can also mean Alexander the Great.
While I do agree with you, doesn't adding the source take care of that problem anyway?
It does, but with that logic full names shouldn't be required since it's rare for a material to have two people in it with the same name. Like you said 'source fix it anyway' so the character won't be interchanged with other similar characters. But with this the rule will be voided as Haruhi (Ouran High School Host Club) will be differentiated from Haruhi (Melancholy of ahhh fuck) similar to Rider (Fate/Zero) will be differentiated from Rider (Fate/SN). However we have a full name rule that adds complexity to the mix. So we will have Haruhi Fujioka (Ouran) and Haruhi Suzumiya (Melancholy) but retain Rider (Fate/Zero) and Rider (Fate/SN)? It just seems awkward to me for some reason.
0
luinthoron
High Priest of Loli
Ryouma Sakamoto wrote...
luinthoron wrote...
Ryouma Sakamoto wrote...
Last reset we got to keep 3, the later 2, now 1 so yes I am implying that she might be claimable if waar decides a whole wipe out in the next game.In the case of Saber since there's only one saber being Arthuria Pendragon it's okay. But for the case of Rider and Caster it's different since Fate/Zero Riders and Casters are men. If someone claims Rider and someone claims Rider Medusa the Gorgon I feel that the second should be more legitimate since Rider can also mean Alexander the Great.
While I do agree with you, doesn't adding the source take care of that problem anyway?
It does, but with that logic full names shouldn't be required since it's rare for a material to have two people in it with the same name. Like you said 'source fix it anyway' so the character won't be interchanged with other similar characters. But with this the rule will be voided as Haruhi (Ouran High School Host Club) will be differentiated from Haruhi (Melancholy of ahhh fuck) similar to Rider (Fate/Zero) will be differentiated from Rider (Fate/SN). However we have a full name rule that adds complexity to the mix. So we will have Haruhi Fujioka (Ouran) and Haruhi Suzumiya (Melancholy) but retain Rider (Fate/Zero) and Rider (Fate/SN)? It just seems awkward to me for some reason.
As said, I do agree with you.
I also don't think anyone would be dumb enough to just say Haruhi without any last name, nor should they be allowed to. Fate/whatever is somewhat of a special case, though, since these characters are mainly known just by these names.
0
Hentanize
rebaS
t retain Rider (Fate/Zero) and Rider (Fate/SN)? It just seems awkward to me for some reason.
I don't think it's THAT awkward, i mean... Even if they share the same name, we've got sigs to clarify everything out.
And yea, i don't think we should push that debate so far. Regarding Fate/whatever, just put down their class name and the series they belong to. It's a LIST we're talking about, no need for aesthetics.
Last reset we got to keep 3, the later 2, now 1 so yes I am implying that she might be claimable if waar decides a whole wipe out in the next game.
Meh, after everything i've been through, i just hope it won't happen.
0
Hentanize wrote...
t retain Rider (Fate/Zero) and Rider (Fate/SN)? It just seems awkward to me for some reason.
I don't think it's THAT awkward, i mean... Even if they share the same name, we've got sigs to clarify everything out.
lol dont be fooled but some sigs here are a year's old and I know someone who still keeps the sigs which contains his old waifus and still uses it.
Anyway the main point is that I pretty much think if we allow claiming by only saying "Rider" and "Caster" there will be a huge loop hole in the rule. So if the character is popular by 'this name'
it should be allowed? It kinda drills a huge loop hole around the rule in which it's as if the rule didn't even exist. But I'm okay with claiming by popular aliases but I think it demeaners the rule about using full names. Mind you it also breaks another rule "not claiming of species and races" because Rider is in itself a class of a servant not the actual person.
0
Nashrakh
Little White Butterflies Staff
luinthoron wrote...
oneshott wrote...
luinthoron wrote...
Different Lamia is different.He married his own drawings?
So he did.
So I can use that loophole to make up characters. NICE
0
luinthoron
High Priest of Loli
Nashrakh wrote...
luinthoron wrote...
oneshott wrote...
luinthoron wrote...
Different Lamia is different.He married his own drawings?
So he did.
So I can use that loophole to make up characters. NICE
No, you can not. He married her in the first game before Waar forbid this, so that's why the exception.
0
luinthoron wrote...
No, you can not.Chill broski, he's just messing around
Waifu List 6/08
Spoiler:
0
luinthoron
High Priest of Loli
oneshott wrote...
luinthoron wrote...
No, you can not.Chill broski, he's just messing around
Considering that it was Nash, it was pretty clear. But some others might still get that idea, so better to have the answer here as well.
0
luinthoron
High Priest of Loli
sepias wrote...
i claim Mayumi Thyme from Shuffle! ;A;Spoiler:
Congratulations on a great choice. Finished the VN just yesterday, definitely one of the greatest girls there. If only the new version that has her too would be translated as well...
0
luinthoron wrote...
sepias wrote...
i claim Mayumi Thyme from Shuffle! ;A;Spoiler:
Congratulations on a great choice. Finished the VN just yesterday, definitely one of the greatest girls there. If only the new version that has her too would be translated as well...
O.O SEP CLAIMED MAYUMI??? Man and I thought he wasn't interested in the waifu game, got a hell of a pick though. I was always a bit annoyed she wasn't a love interest in the original Shuffle.
0
luinthoron
High Priest of Loli
Kyuubi no Shinigami wrote...
luinthoron wrote...
sepias wrote...
i claim Mayumi Thyme from Shuffle! ;A;Spoiler:
Congratulations on a great choice. Finished the VN just yesterday, definitely one of the greatest girls there. If only the new version that has her too would be translated as well...
O.O SEP CLAIMED MAYUMI??? Man and I thought he wasn't interested in the waifu game, got a hell of a pick though. I was always a bit annoyed she wasn't a love interest in the original Shuffle.
Yeah... She was probably the first girl I really started to like there, even if not my absolute favorite in the end.
0
luinthoron wrote...
Kyuubi no Shinigami wrote...
luinthoron wrote...
sepias wrote...
i claim Mayumi Thyme from Shuffle! ;A;Spoiler:
Congratulations on a great choice. Finished the VN just yesterday, definitely one of the greatest girls there. If only the new version that has her too would be translated as well...
O.O SEP CLAIMED MAYUMI??? Man and I thought he wasn't interested in the waifu game, got a hell of a pick though. I was always a bit annoyed she wasn't a love interest in the original Shuffle.
Yeah... She was probably the first girl I really started to like there, even if not my absolute favorite in the end.
Yeah same here. She was interesting, plus I gotta say I have a thing for heterochromia-eyed girls. Well anyway I'll just have to wait until Shuffle Essence+ is translated...however long that'll take.
0
Sabers Praetor
Unlimited Lewd Works
Mayumi is an interesting character but I don't find her all that sexually attractive I am more looking forward to Miss B. and Kareha >.>
0
Sorrow Bloodmist wrote...
Mayumi is an interesting character but I don't find her all that sexually attractive I am more looking forward to Miss B. and Kareha >.>Eh I've got vary wide taste, big small either is good in my opinion.
0
Sabers Praetor
Unlimited Lewd Works
I prefer mid-large but not oversized basically no washboards and no gigantic tits
some exceptions may occur based on personality
some exceptions may occur based on personality
0
True true, both extremes can be a bit unappealing. The girl has a good enough personality though and it doesn't matter as much.
0
luinthoron
High Priest of Loli
Sorrow Bloodmist wrote...
Mayumi is an interesting character but I don't find her all that sexually attractive I am more looking forward to Miss B. and Kareha >.>Miss B. is another one I'm looking forward to as well. And also Kikyou.