Space Cowboy wrote...
No one in here has suggested any other actor more suitable for the character of Spike, but I think any one would just scream, "NO, WHY!?!?!?!?!11" with pretty much any actor.
I wouldn't say I screamed "NO, WHY!?!?!?!?!11" when they announced Reeves would play Spike, it's just that he is very engraved in a certain character type right now. His past few performances have all been the same kind of gruff, static feel to them (The Day the Earth Stood Still, A Scanner Darkly, The Lake House, The Matrix etc). Granted, it worked in some of those movies, they cast the character to fit Reeve, but this time he is playing a role that we all know quite well so we have much higher expectations on how that character should act. As long as Reeve actually plays the character (as in wait for a trailer and see) I have no problem with it, it's just I keep imagining, as I'm sure many others do, he pulls a Klatu in a Spike outfit. As for your point of complaining about any actor they picked, personally, I would probably agree with you. There will never be anyone who will EXATLY fit the image of Spike we all want, that would actually require turning some dude 2D. It's the same problem with all adaptations, actors not meeting the representations of the character that would make the fans happy. There has to be a fair compromise, and while I can't think of anyone offhand, I'm sure there must be someone better suited to the role than Reeves, give the point mentioned above.
Space Cowboy wrote...
The fact that Sunrise is going to be working so closely and hard on this means it can't be completely butchered unless they've lost their minds.
I hope your right, though the idea that there has never been a good american anime adaptation yet (purely subjective mind you, im sure others may disagree) kind of stands in the way of being too overly positive on the situation. I hope, I really do, that the first trailer hits and we can be like 'yes, awesome, totally wrong about everything we were worried about', we will see...