Dogma vs Fight Club

plot wise, which do you prefer? Which was better.

Dogma, it isn't pretending to be more clever than it really is.

i like both of them but i will have to go with the one i own so dogma.

I prefer Fight Club. Dogma, to me, tries too hard. It has all these spiels about religion, and while some of the stuff is funny, most of it isn't needed. But I say that as a big Kevin Smith fan. I love everything he does, but Dogma just focuses too much on saying shit about religion and not saying funny shit. Still a great movie though.

I personally much prefer Fight Club, but I've never really been a Kevin Smith fan. I realize that his movies, like "Clerks", were important in developing certain genres of film, but I've never enjoyed watching them. Fight Club, on the other hand, I really enjoyed watching.

Fight Club by far! I love the twists and turns that are crazily bizarre and fun one of the best movies ever. Dogmas not bad though just not as good.

Dogma. Not only does it surpass Fight Club in every way, it is one of my favorite movies of all time.

not shocked.

Dogma, It's also my favorite movie of all time.

I like the one club that shall not be talked about over Dogma, but you had to be all specific an' shit so plotwise it'd be Dogma.