Signature showdown, Yama-kun vs Kuro vi Lolitannia

So me and Kuro decided to have a contest on who made the best signature and which one you people like best. We're just doing it just for fun to see who is the most interesting signature.

I also wanted to see what you people think about our signature, and try to see the difference between our works.

First comes Kuro's signature. The theme hasn't been chosen, so it was surprising for me to see it. So Kuro chose the theme Fakku. Some details has been added by Kuro himself.

Kuro's signature:
Fonts : Arial Black & HandelGotD
Backgrounds : Bunch of my favorite doujins, there're Kanade, Sengoku, Azunyan, Mio, and Stocking
Picture : Cute Momoka pic~ I got it from this site of course
The signature (Uploaded by using http://www.min.us/ )


The second one is mine of course

My theme has been stucked in my head in the whole day so I had to get it out. My theme is "nice guys", which actually is a song. Not much of a theme, but I did my best to prove what I can do with photoshop and that's the tool I used to make my signature.

Yama-kun's signature
Font: I used a font, just to be part of the background, but that's all.
Background: Made it myself and mixed up many colors and filter to make it looks like just in the signature.
Picture: Miharu Rokujou
Signature: (Is been uploaded in http://www.Sadpanda.us/)

Ah... That's the pic of Miharu Rokujou from Nabari no Ou~~

Nice background, I'm not good at creating background....

I personally have no skill at making sig, but from my point of view kuros sig look nice. So my vote goes too kuro.

point goes to Kuro.

I liked Kuro's one. I'd actually like to have a similar sig like this one.

I voted Kuro's.
It looks more badass and would actually work well for a new F banner.

If Yama had made something like his Touhou sig, I think he'd have got much more votes.

I like both. They are equal for me, but I go for yama-kun´s signatures.

Didn´t forget that epic signature which he made for me.

Voted for Yama, I like the background. Kuro's could make for a nice F! banner though. Both sigs arent bad at all.

I like yama's since of the way it conveys his message and how it presents itself.

Loli's is good but because of the gray background it seems... well too plain. But the theme he chose as FAKKU fits the sig very well.

I choose you! Yama.

Yama onii-chan for me~~~

Both are great, done very well.
Like backgrond in both.
However i can vote only for one, and that one is Yama

Yama's sig is great, but Kuro's fakku is greater for me.

Sir YAMA for me...

Yama's sig for me.

1. I can't make a good background for shit
2. Kuro's, like Hajo said, would make for a better banner than a sig... rather I'd like to see it as a button on other sites to link to Fakku =D That'd be *Cr1TiKaL voice* awesome
3. Yama's sig really looks like a sig

It's a signature contest people, not a banner contest. Make up your mind. I'm speaking to people that talks about banner.

I like kuros sig more. The black and white bg make the text and Momoka pop out nicely and I also like it how its not just a plain square, it looks a bit different because Momoka is a little bit bigger than the background.
And I'm not really a fan of random (or less random) texts on the background for some reason.

[size=9]Also, cute Momoka vs some random guy from some anime/manga I know nothing about. I'm a girl, but I prefer cute girls over guys, because animu guys = meh imo D:[/h]

It's not random if you read closely what I have wrote.

How can you call it random when I have put all my feeling into one little signature?

Aww, I didnt mean it like that. Its just that I havent watched the anime nor read the manga he's from, so I dont know him. He's just an emtpy shell to me you know. And I know I dont know Momoka either, but at least her empty shell has cute boobs, bum and other girly features :p
Maybe I should just shut up? :

Don't take my word so harsh. I don't even know him either, until Kuro said where he was from.

The point of my signature is make people to see the way how a "nice guy" feels. You know all sad and dark. Well not so very dark. The words/sentence in the background is a lyrics of a song, actually.

So my point is that people will see that I have put some feelings in it, and not only art. But people doesn't see that after all.