The Great Debate.
The Great Debate.
0
i've never posted on a poll before... but now i think i must. yamatogawa ftw.
but gunma is still very good, in his own.
but gunma is still very good, in his own.
0
I'm a huge fan of Gunma because his works have always *served* their purpose for me the best out of any manga I've ever read. Their basic set-up and story is just perfect enough for all the H scenes, and I think the girls have a lot more personality, so my vote goes to him.
0
Gunma is pretty good, but Yamatogawa is just so much better!
Both of their art is good, but again Yamatogawa is better.
Both of their art is good, but again Yamatogawa is better.
0
Gunma Kisaragi, hands down. I like both of their drawing styles, but Gunma's plot lines are better and, well, moar selection.
0
for storyline, I like Yamatogawa, but for Artwork Gunma is better... so, whom i vote for?? who knows ^^
0
It's like telling me to do the impossible T_T
On the one hand I started with Witchcraft, Yamatogawa's other manga, and quickl moved into Tayu Tayu. On the other hand I have been a gunma fan for a while as well, and I love Gunma's work. Still in the case I have to say that Yamatogawa has done more, and although they are about equal I will vote Yamatogawa because Love Selection just doesn't do it for me like Tayu Tayu, and Witchcraft XD
Then again I suppose I should be happy it wasn't somethng like Nekomata Naomi vs. Gust. (That wouldhave made me explode trying to think about it T_T)
On the one hand I started with Witchcraft, Yamatogawa's other manga, and quickl moved into Tayu Tayu. On the other hand I have been a gunma fan for a while as well, and I love Gunma's work. Still in the case I have to say that Yamatogawa has done more, and although they are about equal I will vote Yamatogawa because Love Selection just doesn't do it for me like Tayu Tayu, and Witchcraft XD
Then again I suppose I should be happy it wasn't somethng like Nekomata Naomi vs. Gust. (That wouldhave made me explode trying to think about it T_T)
0
I'll have to pick Gunma because he make great doujin! i like his Love-Selection and Mai favorite. Ahahahaha
^__^
^__^
0
daemon84
Mega Milk
voted for Gunma because he got more works I like!
but TayuTayu and newer works from Yamatogawa are excellent and I like it as much as Gunma :)
very close for both...
but TayuTayu and newer works from Yamatogawa are excellent and I like it as much as Gunma :)
very close for both...
0
i chose Kisaragi Gunma because the because i favor the more stylized type of art over yamatogawa's. i have read more of gunma's works and prefer the story also. that isnt to say that yamatogawa's artwork or story is bad, cause it is also excellent. its a personal preference as others have noted.
0
Difference of only around 500 votes with over 6000 voters... this indeed is the Great Debate. I haven't seen the % really move, Gumna at 53% and Yamatogawa at 46%.
