The Great Debate.

It's more like Giri Giri Sisters & Mai Favorite & Love Selection vs. Witchcraft & Tayu Tayu & Aqua Bless. The similarities between these two sets are kind of astounding, which is why I believe that the match-up between these two is almost dead even.

I voted Gunma over Yamatogawa because the latter's regular works don't really have the (let's be generous here) plot depth I prefer.

Kisaragi Gunma....let's ride!
Lock it in!

Gunma's art are really cool, and a number of his stories and setting are really to my liking as well as it being very clean cut.

I like Yamatogawa's faces better than Gunma's, but the overall attention to detail that Gunma displays in his word impresses me far more.

Plus his stories are just sexy.

Dude. This is truly a great debate. These two have such a gift. A perverted gift but a gift anyways. Love all their work so far. Voted for Yamatogawa on flip of a coin.

I wonder what if someone could combine their brains?

Gunma's actress is more adult-like(more developed & realistic faces) than Yamatogawa, which I think prefer cuter actress.

Both of them have a good taste and are creative in developing their own storyline. Yamatogawa create a lot 'weird' and hot girls(Shinoh for example) in tayu-tayu. Gunma, I think also create some 'weird' and hot girls + deeper storyline in his creation.


since I haven't read all of their work, I would judge them ONLY from Tayu-tayu & Mai Favorite. And the winner is....... Gunma

Gunma i guess, since i favor his faces more.

*votes for gunma*

I love Gunma's work.....but Yamatogawa edges out a victory imo.

Both Gunma and Yamatogawa is great in art and story
but Yamatogawa have a better art^^

I personally like both artist but too bad i have to chose only one

Yeah i like the artwork by yamatogawa a lot more than i like gunma

Giri - Giri Sisters, Mai Favorite, and other releases of Kisaragi Gunma is much better than Tayu - Tayu series from Yamatogawa.

I gotta go with Yamatogawa, after all Witchcraft is one of my all time favorite manga.

Yamatogawa

His characters are more real, not only in respect to their looks but also in personality. Yeah, his figures HAVE some personality!

Those with eyes can see that Gunma has great drawing skills but his characters tend to lose her mind too willingingly and just start to fuck out of the blue.

Yamatogawa always provided his stories with some funny moments, it's never boring to read his bunko because he can change his set-ups and seems to have fun doing so.

Gunma relies too much of his artworks. I can't remember of a story with a decent scenario which deserves to be called that way. I have the impression that he uses clichés too much. His works are a feast to the eyes but no more. A good but easy read.

I'm always really exited to see Yamatogawa releasing a new work, impatiently waiting for the translation. Yeah, if I could, I would give him more than this single vote!