[Summer Contest Entry 2012] Surprise!
                    0
                
                        
                        Here's my story:
Surprise!
Word Count: 1,315
Supplementary Information: To be honest I'm really unhappy with this piece. I wanted to write something more profound but couldn't think of anything so I decided to just write a straight up mech combat story for fun. In the end I felt it ended up meandering and going nowhere. I just couldn't find any inspiration for this contest.
Still I'm happy to have kicked it out the door. If nothing else this contest gives me incentive to write and every story I write brings me one`step closer to writing...a better story. So I hope you lot enjoy this more than I did writing it.
A note on the mechs: The mecha in this story are loosely based on a mecha universe of my own creation which in turn is inspired by various mecha I've seen on TV and in video games. The mech heads among you will be able to pick out references to the most prominent influences in the text itself.
Here's a "deleted scene" that I thought was more humorous but was cut from the original story because I felt it was unwieldy. Judges are encouraged not to read it until the contest is over.
                    
                Surprise!
Spoiler:
Word Count: 1,315
Supplementary Information: To be honest I'm really unhappy with this piece. I wanted to write something more profound but couldn't think of anything so I decided to just write a straight up mech combat story for fun. In the end I felt it ended up meandering and going nowhere. I just couldn't find any inspiration for this contest.
Still I'm happy to have kicked it out the door. If nothing else this contest gives me incentive to write and every story I write brings me one`step closer to writing...a better story. So I hope you lot enjoy this more than I did writing it.
A note on the mechs: The mecha in this story are loosely based on a mecha universe of my own creation which in turn is inspired by various mecha I've seen on TV and in video games. The mech heads among you will be able to pick out references to the most prominent influences in the text itself.
Here's a "deleted scene" that I thought was more humorous but was cut from the original story because I felt it was unwieldy. Judges are encouraged not to read it until the contest is over.
Spoiler:
                    0
                
                        
                        Review #6
The Good: I always enjoy a good mech warrior story. As for the entire battle, it was clearly visual. I'm assuming you write stories for these kinds of things in general. In terms of pacing, it was well done. A slight joke in the beginning with slowly increasing action as the story progressed. Every description was clear and in the moment. A solid piece.
Grammer: OK
The Okay/Bad: Inherently, there really is nothing "bad" about this piece. I feel that as an anecdote in a larger story, it would be an interesting piece, but in the context of the summer contest... the fuck? What on earth does this have to do with the themes: Romance, Summer, or Vacation? I assumed you'd try to get away with throwing the word summer into it or adding some random vacation element, but even that wasn't in here. In fact, this has nothing to do with the contest at all. You merely made a random story in 1500 words or less. That is possible for anyone really. It's the restrictive element of themes and FAKKU that make this contest interesting.
                The Good: I always enjoy a good mech warrior story. As for the entire battle, it was clearly visual. I'm assuming you write stories for these kinds of things in general. In terms of pacing, it was well done. A slight joke in the beginning with slowly increasing action as the story progressed. Every description was clear and in the moment. A solid piece.
Grammer: OK
The Okay/Bad: Inherently, there really is nothing "bad" about this piece. I feel that as an anecdote in a larger story, it would be an interesting piece, but in the context of the summer contest... the fuck? What on earth does this have to do with the themes: Romance, Summer, or Vacation? I assumed you'd try to get away with throwing the word summer into it or adding some random vacation element, but even that wasn't in here. In fact, this has nothing to do with the contest at all. You merely made a random story in 1500 words or less. That is possible for anyone really. It's the restrictive element of themes and FAKKU that make this contest interesting.
                    0
                
                        CoffeePrince wrote...
Review #6The Good: I always enjoy a good mech warrior story. As for the entire battle, it was clearly visual. I'm assuming you write stories for these kinds of things in general. In terms of pacing, it was well done. A slight joke in the beginning with slowly increasing action as the story progressed. Every description was clear and in the moment. A solid piece.
Grammer: OK
The Okay/Bad: Inherently, there really is nothing "bad" about this piece. I feel that as an anecdote in a larger story, it would be an interesting piece, but in the context of the summer contest... the fuck? What on earth does this have to do with the themes: Romance, Summer, or Vacation? I assumed you'd try to get away with throwing the word summer into it or adding some random vacation element, but even that wasn't in here. In fact, this has nothing to do with the contest at all. You merely made a random story in 1500 words or less. That is possible for anyone really. It's the restrictive element of themes and FAKKU that make this contest interesting.
Thanks for your review. I actually agree with you on the subject of the contest theme. Perhaps I would have been able to write something with more depth had I allowed myself to be guided by the contest themes rather than trying to shoe horn them into the story I wanted to write. That's definitely something I'll take into account when the next contest rolls round.
                    0
                
                        
                        Cinia Pacifica
                                                    Ojou-sama Writer
                                            
                    
                    
                    
                
                        Review #3
Comments:
- Just another in the life of a guy in the military, I'm not a fan of those, but that doesn't mean that they can't be good.
- This isn't a bad story with all the action, but it isn't really good, especially with it being seemingly hollow. Why do I say it? Because the fight is the only main thing we know and read about, there isn't much going on other than that. We don't really know what this mission the main character is venturing the skies for, nor do we know much about the character himself. Why does he work there? Does he really enjoy working like this instead of living a more relaxed life? In short, it leaves some questions that are better to be answered than to be left to the readers to answer.
- The action itself was quite nice though. However, I think an improvement in imagery can make that fighting scenes way better.
- You could have removed some useless part and added more parts that could actually make this entry a better one. If I'm correct, the word count result showed like 1300 or so words.
- This entry kind of made me want to read more, but I believe that's only because a part of my username was put to use.
- It's easy to read and goes smooth, but if I remember correctly; there are some silly mistakes scattered around the entry which disrupts it.
- I'd recommend you to write something that actually leaves a good message for the readers. Make sure you leave a lasting impression upon your readers. Next time, try to write a piece that is truly unique and original as much as possible!
In-depth views based on the categories:
Grammar/spelling - A few mistakes here and there. Everything else seems fine.
Plot - This is just me, but there isn't much going on in this story other than a mission the readers don't know much about and a fight between life and death. While the life is important, what concerns that too, is important.
Themes - It's like you said shrugged the themes aside and just put the word "Summer" to make this entry legitimate?
Flow - It was quite smooth, especially during the fight scenes.
Originality - I haven't read many of such stories since I'm not a huge fan of Gundam, mecha series or the likes. But thinking with common sense, events of such a tale are so probable in animes series contain mechs.
                Comments:
- Just another in the life of a guy in the military, I'm not a fan of those, but that doesn't mean that they can't be good.
- This isn't a bad story with all the action, but it isn't really good, especially with it being seemingly hollow. Why do I say it? Because the fight is the only main thing we know and read about, there isn't much going on other than that. We don't really know what this mission the main character is venturing the skies for, nor do we know much about the character himself. Why does he work there? Does he really enjoy working like this instead of living a more relaxed life? In short, it leaves some questions that are better to be answered than to be left to the readers to answer.
- The action itself was quite nice though. However, I think an improvement in imagery can make that fighting scenes way better.
- You could have removed some useless part and added more parts that could actually make this entry a better one. If I'm correct, the word count result showed like 1300 or so words.
- This entry kind of made me want to read more, but I believe that's only because a part of my username was put to use.
- It's easy to read and goes smooth, but if I remember correctly; there are some silly mistakes scattered around the entry which disrupts it.
- I'd recommend you to write something that actually leaves a good message for the readers. Make sure you leave a lasting impression upon your readers. Next time, try to write a piece that is truly unique and original as much as possible!
In-depth views based on the categories:
Grammar/spelling - A few mistakes here and there. Everything else seems fine.
Plot - This is just me, but there isn't much going on in this story other than a mission the readers don't know much about and a fight between life and death. While the life is important, what concerns that too, is important.
Themes - It's like you said shrugged the themes aside and just put the word "Summer" to make this entry legitimate?
Flow - It was quite smooth, especially during the fight scenes.
Originality - I haven't read many of such stories since I'm not a huge fan of Gundam, mecha series or the likes. But thinking with common sense, events of such a tale are so probable in animes series contain mechs.
                    0
                
                        
                        Wow...can't believed I missed this gem of a story.
Good: Damn, AMAZING mech action. As a fan of mechs, I enjoy any story like this. Actually, that is why I was so critical of Pulse of the Stars, since it was a Gundam-related story with no action. With your exquisite use of details, I could just imagine Deckard's situation and I'll give you additional props for putting him in a lower ranked suit compared to his foes. I can go on and on, but I think you get the idea that I enjoy this story much more than the others I've read due to a personal bias.
Bad: Unfortunately, just as equally, I can see many flaws with this work. Unlike Pulse of the Stars, this is all mech action and no romance, and barely qualifies as part of summer. I'd like to think that this isn't a vacation. All in all, it barely utilizes the themes and even the FAKKU reference is a bit of a throw-in opposed to something integral. Additionally, I feel that this is part of a larger work that you've submitted for the purpose of the competition opposed to something that can stand on its own. I had a ton of unanswered questions at the end, such as why Deckard was there and who he was working for. I think my last gripe is that Deckard, while in a lower-ranked mech, essentially pulled a Kira Yamato. Actually, it was EXACTLY like what happened in GSD Episode 34/35. By all means, Deckard should've died. I understand an explosion and surviving, but a stab through the cockpit should be a deathblow no matter what. Considering the status of Deckard's mech, I can't see why he would survive and what's worse, that the enemy wouldn't finish him off.
Even though I am listing a ton of issues I've had, this is by far one of my favorite stories that I have read, just because it satisfied my itch for mech combat.
                Good: Damn, AMAZING mech action. As a fan of mechs, I enjoy any story like this. Actually, that is why I was so critical of Pulse of the Stars, since it was a Gundam-related story with no action. With your exquisite use of details, I could just imagine Deckard's situation and I'll give you additional props for putting him in a lower ranked suit compared to his foes. I can go on and on, but I think you get the idea that I enjoy this story much more than the others I've read due to a personal bias.
Bad: Unfortunately, just as equally, I can see many flaws with this work. Unlike Pulse of the Stars, this is all mech action and no romance, and barely qualifies as part of summer. I'd like to think that this isn't a vacation. All in all, it barely utilizes the themes and even the FAKKU reference is a bit of a throw-in opposed to something integral. Additionally, I feel that this is part of a larger work that you've submitted for the purpose of the competition opposed to something that can stand on its own. I had a ton of unanswered questions at the end, such as why Deckard was there and who he was working for. I think my last gripe is that Deckard, while in a lower-ranked mech, essentially pulled a Kira Yamato. Actually, it was EXACTLY like what happened in GSD Episode 34/35. By all means, Deckard should've died. I understand an explosion and surviving, but a stab through the cockpit should be a deathblow no matter what. Considering the status of Deckard's mech, I can't see why he would survive and what's worse, that the enemy wouldn't finish him off.
Even though I am listing a ton of issues I've had, this is by far one of my favorite stories that I have read, just because it satisfied my itch for mech combat.
 
                         
                         
                        