The Greatest Gift (Enhanced Ver.)

Pages 12Next
1
AssasinZAssasin Not Hentai Protagonist
Link to original work: https://www.fakku.net/viewtopic.php?t=77861

Hey! So, apparently it's been about a year or so since my first submission of "The Greatest Gift" In the Seasonal Writing Contest, which got me my first finalist place on this site's writing contests...It is one of those stories i am really proud of. So, as i promised a year ago, i upgraded this story. Hopefully you would find it better than last time!

Yes, i am aware Christmas is well past, but i would love some reviews for my enchanced piece of writing! Hopefully it's as good as some expected it to be...

Some notable edits - Original protagonist name "John" is now "Wilfred".
- FAKKU industries is now "TopNotch" industries, due to the contest i entered requiring a proper name.

Yeah, So click dat spoilz button below 'ere.

Spoiler:
The Greatest Gift

Christmas Eve, the season to be jolly! Where people celebrate, where children salivate, where workers take a hard earned break. Shops are closed, presents are wrapped, and lovers cuddle, while those alone wept.

It was a wintry night, and a solitary young man strode along the snow caked streets. His jacket hung loose and his scarf was wrapped tightly around his neck. He was shivering in his stride, lost in his thoughts.

He looked around, left and right. There were shops all around, but none were open. He watched lovers cuddled up on benches, and silently yearned for such warmth. Ever since the death of his parents, he had not known love. 8 years spent in a run-down orphanage, forced to leave as he had come of age…2 years spent in a factory, working to his earn next-to-nothing salary, barely managing to put food on his table.

The whisper of a cooling breeze shook him out of his reminiscence. He checked his watch and sighed. He tried to move but fell over in his attempt.

“Just great, my feet fell asleep.” He sighed as he tried to get up.

“Oh, what’s this? Willy, my boy…I knew you were under poor circumstances but to sleep here? On the sidewalk?” A sarcastic voice piped up and Wilfred instantly knew who it belonged to.

“What do you want, Mark? Flaunt your cash and women at me again?” Wilfred spat.
“Spare me, because I’ve had enough of a day without seeing your wretched face.” Wilfred got up and glared at him.

Mark shoved him to the ground and laughed haughtily, proclaiming, “I can’t help it that I was born with a rich daddy and mumsy. Oh wait, I forgot, that’s something you don’t have, hah!”

Wilfred gritted his teeth and brushed past.

“Hey, I’m not done with you! Get back here!” Mark’s voice faded out as Wilfred moved further away.

Wilfred passed by a which stood as a barrier between him and the biggest building in his hometown…The door to TopNotch Industries, the company owned solely by Mark’s father.

“This company bankrupted my employers…And now I’m wandering the streets, doing odd jobs just to get a square meal every day.” Wilfred muttered resentfully.

Wilfred didn’t know what he wanted to do. He was merely wandering the snowy streets with its icy breeze, hoping for inspiration.

The job listing board was frosted over with ice, evidence of the frigid winter. Wilfred could have asked his relatives for money, but he didn’t want to. They were stretched thin as it is.

“I wonder, is this sort of life is worth living?” Wilfred thought out loud. Wilfred could have given up. He got a rope on his 20th birthday from Mark, as a joke perhaps…; or more likely, bait.

Wilfred’s parents were supposed to leave behind an inheritance, but one day it just disappeared, probably stolen. The fact that Wilfred even had a place to live was a miracle. However, despite his circumstances, he was determined to survive in this world.

Wilfred passed by the graveyard and, after a moment of hesitation, went in. He walked over to his parents’ gravestone.

“Mom, Dad…It’s been 10 years, soon to be 11 since the day you left me alone in this world… Sometimes, honestly I find myself hating it…Hating you. Why did you leave me? I know you didn’t choose to do it but I just hate that you guys up and left me…” Wilfred gritted his teeth and salty tears flowed down his face as he blinked hard, urging himself to look away from the gravestones.

“Families gather together, celebrating Christmas. Lovers go to fancy restaurants to celebrate Christmas; even workers have their own little party… And here I am, spending some time with my…family.” Wilfred’s thoughts drew a resigned sigh from his lips as he calmed.

Wilfred missed them dearly. He even found himself missing the orphanage - that run-down yet warm place, in which he sought refuge. He missed his caretaker, all his friends, and everyone else at the orphanage.

Wilfred walked over to the orphanage, past the bulletin board. The bulletin board showed any news and upcoming events in town. Wilfred wasn’t surprised to see that TopNotch Industries dominated most of the board with its announcements.

When he arrived at his destination, Wilfred felt a sharp pain in his heart. It was as if someone had driven a stake through it…The orphanage was wrecked and a sign was plastered in front. Judging by the rundown state of the place, it was no surprise that the sign said †˜Lot for sale’. It hurt him deeply. As he observed the desolate orphanage creak in the wind, Wilfred felt as if something, somewhere inside of him had died.

Seeing his childhood home gone, his knees slowly buckled from under him. He fell, almost slowly, into the snow as moisture started to form in his eyes. As the first tears fell and struck the snow, Wilfred couldn't help but remember all his experiences on these grounds. All his friends, his caretaker…The memories were flooding his head so quickly it hurt. Wilfred jolted to his feet and ran away…Ran as far as his legs would take him; his only thought was escaping the pain in the form of his haunted memories.

Images came to him in a flurry, from when he first came to the orphanage, until the day he left. The warmth of his shared bed, his first friend…Fighting over meals and toys, also over who slept on which end of the bed…

The tears of the melancholic nostalgia came with a sharp pain in his heart. He remembered every little detail of his life in the orphanage, the name of his best friend, his first love, the first present he ever received, the warm hugs of the caretaker…

Wilfred tripped over a rock and fell face first into the snow. He slammed the sidewalk with his fist, cursing his inability to do anything for the orphanage he grew up in, wishing he had returned sooner.

He got up, and continued running, turning corners, jumping around fences…Until eventually he ran out of stamina and collapsed.

Wilfred swore to himself. He rose slowly and found himself in front of a bar. His head was clouded. Without thinking straight, he walked inside. He sat himself down at the counter.

“What’ll you be having, Mr. Customer?” The barkeep asked.

“Just give me a cool beer...” Wilfred replied half-heartedly.

As Wilfred waited for his beer as he leaned down against the bar, his head tilted as they rested on his crossed forearms, listening to the static of chatter in the dimly lit space…

“Hey!” The barkeep’s voice broke Wilfred out of his reverie, and as he sat up he saw the glass of a crystal clear drink sliding down the counter toward him.

With a clumsy hand he caught it, holding it in between his hands almost like in prayer. Wilfred took a few sips and savored the cool liquid flowing down his throat. He sighed in relief as he swished the liquid around in the cup.

“So, you have any money for your drink there?' the barkeep asked, leaning over the counter while cleaning the glass he always seemed to be holding. Wilfred reeled back in shock at the realization that he barely had any money to pay.

“Um…No, not really…” Wilfred said nervously. The barkeep stopped cleaning his glass abruptly, his smile disappeared and he slammed the counter.

“You dare come in here and order drinks when you have no money?” The barkeep shouts at the top of his lungs.

Wilfred could only look down regretfully.

“You penniless piece of trash! Get out!” The barkeep shouted.

A man from the nearby table got up and walked over to the scene.

“Calm down, sir. Can’t you just excuse him this once? It’s Christmas! It’s the season for giving, after all.” He said calmly.

“I can’t make a living if penniless bums come in here and order drinks without paying!” The barkeep boomed.

The man sighed and put some money on the table. “This should cover it, yes?” He said.

The barkeep’s eyes shined at the sight of coin and grabbed at it greedily, apparently appeased. “Oh, yes sir. Your patronage is very much appreciated!” He shot a dirty look at Wilfred. Wilfred busied himself with the floor, which became very interesting now that he was avoiding eye contact with the barkeep. The man gave Wilfred a glance and smirked, and then he started towards the door.

As the man left, Wilfred got up and ran out after him. “Wait!” Wilfred shouted.

The man looked back and his face remained indifferent. He stopped and turned around to face Wilfred.

“Who are you? And… why did you help me?” Wilfred said as he halted in front of the man.

“Name’s Jack, and as to why I helped you…Heh, well its Christmas, isn’t it?” Jack smiled.

“What about Christmas? Beer is expensive around here, Jack.” Wilfred persisted. Jack turned around and started walking slowly.

“Remember this; giving is infinitely better than receiving. Being able to give, to see a person happy like that…It’s the greatest gift given to us humans.”

With that, Jack walked off. Wilfred could only stare at his back, wondering how anyone was capable of such kindness.

Wilfred walked home slowly, thinking about the kindness Jack had given him.

“It’s amazing…How can one person endeavor to commit such acts of kindness?” Wilfred thought out loud.

Wilfred was deep in thought as he walked through the city roads, all the while questioning Jack’s act of kindness. It had really struck him, for apart from the orphanage, no one had really ever shown him kindness.

He eventually realized he had walked down the wrong lane.

“Damn it, I walked the wrong way!” Wilfred cursed inwardly. He was disappointed in himself.

A small, weak cough sounded nearby which surprised him.

He looked around but could not see anything else other than the dimly lit streetlight and some dumpsters.

†˜Huh…Was it my imagination? I’m thinking too much, so much more than I usually do.’ Wilfred thought to himself.

Cough…Cough…

No, it’s definitely not my imagination. “What’s going on here?” Wilfred questioned nobody in particular. Puzzled, he scratched his head and looked around for the origin of the strange noise.

He explored the vicinity and found a girl sitting next to the dumpsters. She looked no more than 16, shivering, wearing only a rather worn out dress and holding her knees close to her chest, hugging herself to stay warm.

Wilfred’s heart filled with pity and empathy as he could relate to her suffering. He once went through this…The cold and frosty bite of the wind this time of the year is torture! Wilfred shivered a little as a breeze of the frosty, wintry air blew past. He was barely holding on with his thin jacket and ragged scarf.

But to see her like this, shivering without much clothing in winter… It was a truly heartbreaking sight.

†˜But really, nothing I can do…’ Wilfred thought to himself as he stared at her, eyes stained with pity and sadness.

Wilfred was about to walk away, but Jack’s earlier words resonated in his mind.

“Remember this; giving is infinitely better than receiving. Being able to give, to see a person happy like that…It’s the greatest gift given to us humans.”

Wilfred hesitated before finally making a decision.

He walked up to the girl and knelt down in front of her. She looked at him with shimmering blue eyes, and reeled slightly in fear.

Wilfred extended his hand and smiled at her. He gestured for her to take his hand.

The girl looked confused, but after a moment of hesitation grasped his hand. Wilfred pulled her up and dusted her off.

Wilfred took off his jacket and scarf and put it over her. Wilfred let out a sharp gasp as the wind hit him and shuddered at the frosty bite of the chilly breeze.

The girl looked at him with those shimmering eyes and asked, “Mister, aren’t you cold?”

Her innocence is cute, Wilfred thought. “It’s okay…What’s your name?” Wilfred asked softly.

“…Claire.” She replied after a moment’s hesitation.

Wilfred smiled and gave her a hug. Claire jerked and struggled a little, but didn’t put up much resistance afterwards.

“It may not be much to offer, since I’m poor and all…But would you like to live with me?” Wilfred asked. “You don’t look like you have a place to stay.”

Her eyes started to shine brighter than before... But she looked at him with disbelief.

Wilfred held her hand and led her to his house.

The road home was a silent, heartwarming trip for Wilfred. He felt he had accomplished something great this day, and that he had made someone happy…that he had changed someone’s life for the better.

Claire was quiet on the way, contemplating the change in her luck. She couldn’t believe what was happening, let alone why anyone would do something like what Wilfred did.

“Mister, what’s your name?” Claire asked.

Wilfred turned around and smiled brightly. “How rude of me…Ahem, well, my name is Wilfred.”

Claire repeatedly muttered Wilfred’s name under her breath while they walked.
As they approached Wilfred’s house, she stopped walking. He turned around and looked at her with curiosity.

“Mister Wil, I was just wondering…Why are you doing this?” She asked, peering into his eyes.

Wilfred shrugged.

“Claire…It’s Christmas! It’s the season to be jolly…Not a sad lump by the roadside!” Wilfred said excitedly.

She shook her head.

“No, I mean why…Why are you so kind to me?” She gripped his hand hard and peered into his eyes, looking for an explanation.

Wilfred chuckled at the irony of the situation. He was in a predicament just like this about an hour ago himself.

Wilfred hugged her and smiled under the illumination of a streetlight on that dark, snowy night.

Claire gave a surprised yelp but didn't resist.

Wilfred took a breath of the cool night air before he whispered into her ear.

“Giving is the greatest gift we humans are capable of…”

The End
0
AssasinZAssasin Not Hentai Protagonist
2.3 K or so words...Not too bad, i added quite a chunk of text from the original...Uh, what was it, 1500 words?

Welp, hope you guys enjoy this enhanced piece of my first entry ever on this site!

Any reviews would be much appreciated! Thanks a bunch.
0
I think I reviewed the piece about that time before, ah it brings back memories~

at first it kind of confused me and overall I thought the story before the revision seem to be more 'powerful', but it has some improvement in terms of writing structure, I think? Also, I think the end was pretty well done, compared to the first version which kind of 'hung up', if I remembered it correctly~

it's definitely an improvement of some sort, but I think you might want to try and recapture the magic from the beginning part which I appraised as a 'strong build-up'.

though I think this story might be much better if the wording and descriptions were...simpler? I'm having a hard time reading every English Novels out there so I'm sorry in advance if I couldn't give an elaborate review of it~

overall I could say it's a nice work, keep on writing! =D
0
AssasinZAssasin Not Hentai Protagonist
high_time wrote...
I think I reviewed the piece about that time before, ah it brings back memories~

at first it kind of confused me and overall I thought the story before the revision seem to be more 'powerful', but it has some improvement in terms of writing structure, I think? Also, I think the end was pretty well done, compared to the first version which kind of 'hung up', if I remembered it correctly~

it's definitely an improvement of some sort, but I think you might want to try and recapture the magic from the beginning part which I appraised as a 'strong build-up'.

though I think this story might be much better if the wording and descriptions were...simpler? I'm having a hard time reading every English Novels out there so I'm sorry in advance if I couldn't give an elaborate review of it~

overall I could say it's a nice work, keep on writing! =D


Can you be more specific about that build up? I did feel i sacrificed a bit of something in this that the original had, but i was never sure what it was.

Yeah, that ending was what i planned except for the damn word limit...

Haha, sorry, still stuck in my head since last time my teacher taught me to use literary powerful words...

So yeah! If you could let me know specifically what you mean, i'd love to know. As in the build up part...

Also, the first story i wrote by myself, but this one went through my "personal editor" so i would never really know what i missed...Most creative control was left with me, but a lot of extras are from her help.
0
AssasinZAssasin wrote...
Can you be more specific about that build up? I did feel i sacrificed a bit of something in this that the original had, but i was never sure what it was.

Yeah, that ending was what i planned except for the damn word limit...

Haha, sorry, still stuck in my head since last time my teacher taught me to use literary powerful words...

So yeah! If you could let me know specifically what you mean, i'd love to know. As in the build up part...

Also, the first story i wrote by myself, but this one went through my "personal editor" so i would never really know what i missed...Most creative control was left with me, but a lot of extras are from her help.


Ah I see, that's why the structure seems a bit different~

Well, the build-up that I'm talking about was about using simple wordings to convey powerful emotions, that's all. It might be kind of biased and subjective but I love stories that could be easily be read to the extent which you can get the story's main points thoroughly just by skimming it =D
0
AssasinZAssasin Not Hentai Protagonist
high_time wrote...
AssasinZAssasin wrote...
Can you be more specific about that build up? I did feel i sacrificed a bit of something in this that the original had, but i was never sure what it was.

Yeah, that ending was what i planned except for the damn word limit...

Haha, sorry, still stuck in my head since last time my teacher taught me to use literary powerful words...

So yeah! If you could let me know specifically what you mean, i'd love to know. As in the build up part...

Also, the first story i wrote by myself, but this one went through my "personal editor" so i would never really know what i missed...Most creative control was left with me, but a lot of extras are from her help.


Ah I see, that's why the structure seems a bit different~

Well, the build-up that I'm talking about was about using simple wordings to convey powerful emotions, that's all. It might be kind of biased and subjective but I love stories that could be easily be read to the extent which you can get the story's main points thoroughly just by skimming it =D


Yeah, everybody else who reads says "OMG SUCH SIMPLE EASY ENGLISH HAHA YOUR GRAMMAR SUCKS" or something...

Yeah, i know that feeling...That's what i try to accomplish with my stories but i think it's due to the influence of my work that require my grammar to be powerful for a good report.
0
AssasinZAssasin wrote...
Yeah, everybody else who reads says "OMG SUCH SIMPLE EASY ENGLISH HAHA YOUR GRAMMAR SUCKS" or something...

Yeah, i know that feeling...That's what i try to accomplish with my stories but i think it's due to the influence of my work that require my grammar to be powerful for a good report.


whoa yeah, being in an English-speaking country must be tough =(

well I could only say best of luck regardless of that =D
0
AssasinZAssasin Not Hentai Protagonist
high_time wrote...
AssasinZAssasin wrote...
Yeah, everybody else who reads says "OMG SUCH SIMPLE EASY ENGLISH HAHA YOUR GRAMMAR SUCKS" or something...

Yeah, i know that feeling...That's what i try to accomplish with my stories but i think it's due to the influence of my work that require my grammar to be powerful for a good report.


whoa yeah, being in an English-speaking country must be tough =(

well I could only say best of luck regardless of that =D


Thanks but...

Stupidly enough, many people in my country don't know english at all or just don't speak it as a first language. I blame my education, some of my buds were snobz and well, teachers and lecturers(i suppose i went to good schools) keep telling me to brush up my english.
0
AssasinZAssasin wrote...
Thanks but...

Stupidly enough, many people in my country don't know english at all or just don't speak it as a first language. I blame my education, some of my buds were snobz and well, teachers and lecturers(i suppose i went to good schools) keep telling me to brush up my english.


ah, it's kinda similar to my country too. the difference is, people in here are quite tolerant to bad English, so I guess I'm somewhat lucky...maybe? =D

anyway good education will always come in handy, so at least feel grateful 'bout it mang xD
0
AssasinZAssasin Not Hentai Protagonist
high_time wrote...
AssasinZAssasin wrote...
Thanks but...

Stupidly enough, many people in my country don't know english at all or just don't speak it as a first language. I blame my education, some of my buds were snobz and well, teachers and lecturers(i suppose i went to good schools) keep telling me to brush up my english.


ah, it's kinda similar to my country too. the difference is, people in here are quite tolerant to bad English, so I guess I'm somewhat lucky...maybe? =D

anyway good education will always come in handy, so at least feel grateful 'bout it mang xD


Oh i definitely am, it makes my dream(aspiration) realistic.

You know, i want to be an author next time. Would you buy a copy? XD
0
AssasinZAssasin wrote...
Oh i definitely am, it makes my dream(aspiration) realistic.

You know, i want to be an author next time. Would you buy a copy? XD


I'll think about it, though if the delivery costs and method of payment weren't so bothersome, I'll consider getting a credit card just for this~
0
AssasinZAssasin Not Hentai Protagonist
high_time wrote...
AssasinZAssasin wrote...
Oh i definitely am, it makes my dream(aspiration) realistic.

You know, i want to be an author next time. Would you buy a copy? XD


I'll think about it, though if the delivery costs and method of payment weren't so bothersome, I'll consider getting a credit card just for this~


I'll autograph it with a lil message of my appreciation XD.

Who would ever believe that i improved by joining competitions on a hentai site>?
0
AssasinZAssasin wrote...
I'll autograph it with a lil message of my appreciation XD.

Who would ever believe that i improved by joining competitions on a hentai site>?


that would be much appreciated mang~

reality is stranger than fiction indeed, well I'm looking forward to more things from ya
0
AssasinZAssasin Not Hentai Protagonist
high_time wrote...
AssasinZAssasin wrote...
I'll autograph it with a lil message of my appreciation XD.

Who would ever believe that i improved by joining competitions on a hentai site>?


that would be much appreciated mang~

reality is stranger than fiction indeed, well I'm looking forward to more things from ya


Thanks, counting on your reviews too! Well, be seeing you sometime then, on this site.
0
Dude, finally done reading it, after such a long (as in VERY long) time, haha (sorry about that, couldn't be helped).

It was decent, yeah. The story still got its original idea, though I can see there are stuffs have changed, but in a good way, haha. I can still get this warm feeling like I had back then, hmmmmm.

Let's start with what I like XD. Well, most of it is from the original one you put up here anyway, so pretty much what I like about it is still here. You know, the concept, the characters, yeah. I like how your convey the characters' thoughts, especially how Wil develop his feelings throughout the story. And I think that ending fulfill its purpose of helping us feeling sympathetic with the two poor souls in the winter night. I can also see lines from your new entry in the recent contest, haha.

On to the things that I think still can use a little improving, hmm. First off, the grammatical errors, the thing that haunts us writers most =.= Though you said you did have it checked by your "personal editor", but I can still spot some errors here. Need to work on it, hmm (and maybe that "personal editor" need to, too, hmm, haha, just kidding).

Secondly, as I think I have stated this before last time, too, if my memory is not playing tricks with me right now, I still think it's not very realistic, you know? I'll explain this on every character.

About Mark:

Spoiler:
I immediately have problems with this guy. As I assume from the story, he's a spoilt guy with filthy rich parents and he's also Wil's employer, I'm not wrong, right? But then, how can a rich guy like Mark have anything to do with a poor guy like Wil? I mean, though they can be employer and subordinate, and their relationship is nothing more than hate, and though the gift were means of sarcasm, but giving gift? I know I don't give presents to others unless I'm close with the on a certain level (it may be it's just me). What I mean is, they must have a much more complicated relationship than just that. I mean, if Mark and Wil were to act like they did, they must have a "bond" And bonds aren't just happened to exist, they must be formed through some set of circumstances, right? So I think they should have a more deep background, a backstory of some sort to lead them to be like this. Something goes like: Wil and Mark were raised in the same orphanage, they were best friends, but then Mark's family, which turns out to be the richest in the area, found their long-lost son, which then led Wil to turn his back on Mark - something like that, or anything else you can think of. I want to see to see that backstory part which is now still missing in your story.


About Jack:

Spoiler:
How many times do you go to a bar without money and then a complete stranger pay for your drink? Not many... That's what I think... I mean, helping out others is, of course, what Christmas is all about, I agree, but I would rather they have met in a different situation, where Jack can help Wil out in other way. Even providing that it CAN happen, I don't think paying for a beer packs much of a punch in Wil's mind, I mean, I don't think it can be that influential to make some guy take home some girl on the street... When you think about it, you see, pay for a beer and take home a complete stranger... I hope you can get what I mean up till now...


About Wilfred and Claire:

Spoiler:
As I have stated before, also, last time, the way Wil is taking someone he has just met on the street sounds really unbelievable. Maybe you wrote that to elevate the touching level of the piece, which I guess kinda works, but still, I don't anyone would do that, not even some rich humanitarian, let alone some seriously-broke guy who can barely take of himself. But it's seriously touched my heart. Then again, you might to work on it to make it a little more bit "real". And also, this guy is really weak, both emotionally and physically. I mean, when I read this, he was falling to the ground all over, I was like "It's this guy for real?". I think we don't fall to the ground these days, which you can only see that in manga now. Even if you can do that now, I think they would only do that when there's a climax mental breakdown because of some truths or something, which I think all the situations in the piece failed to reach that much... And also the way he hug Claire. I don't really know about others, but we don't hug that much here, but I don't think he can hug her so dearly but so casually like that. I mean, when I read that last part of the story, the image I got in my head makes me think that Wil had known Claire for a lifetime already, not just some girl he has just met. Claire was, well, totally fine with me, nothing I would change about her.


Also things about the setting of the story, too:

Spoiler:
I would rather had it more carefully described, but I guess it's still fine if it's not. But I do have some other problems. First, the orphanage. It must be somewhere in town, yeah? But then, it's strange he doesn't visit often. One time he finally decide to, then it turns out to be nowhere to be seen, that's just sad... One more important thing. You set the story in the Christmas night, right? Of course that's when people get out of the house and do something outside, so the streets have got to be packed, right? However, when I read the story, I don't think there's anyone at all on the streets, which is extremely weird. Somewhere near a bar must be crowded. Or is it that everyone is so frigid to each other that they don't even care if there's a guy fainting in front of them? Not just that scene, throughout the whole story, I can't see almost no one else apart from the four main characters, and that's not good.


Thanks if you have read to this point. Though I have said much, and I'm sorry if I sounds harsh, but I still fully enjoyed it and I think it's touching and the piece just speak to me. You have definitely made it better. And I just want you to know that, the whole thing is written with a big "IF I WERE YOU" on top, so yeah, everything is my subjective opinions, you can discard this thing, hahah.

Well, be sure to reply if you read this, 'kay?
0
AssasinZAssasin Not Hentai Protagonist
Dawn_of_Dark wrote...
Dude, finally done reading it, after such a long (as in VERY long) time, haha (sorry about that, couldn't be helped).

It was decent, yeah. The story still got its original idea, though I can see there are stuffs have changed, but in a good way, haha. I can still get this warm feeling like I had back then, hmmmmm.

Let's start with what I like XD. Well, most of it is from the original one you put up here anyway, so pretty much what I like about it is still here. You know, the concept, the characters, yeah. I like how your convey the characters' thoughts, especially how Wil develop his feelings throughout the story. And I think that ending fulfill its purpose of helping us feeling sympathetic with the two poor souls in the winter night. I can also see lines from your new entry in the recent contest, haha.

On to the things that I think still can use a little improving, hmm. First off, the grammatical errors, the thing that haunts us writers most =.= Though you said you did have it checked by your "personal editor", but I can still spot some errors here. Need to work on it, hmm (and maybe that "personal editor" need to, too, hmm, haha, just kidding).

Secondly, as I think I have stated this before last time, too, if my memory is not playing tricks with me right now, I still think it's not very realistic, you know? I'll explain this on every character.

About Mark:

Spoiler:
I immediately have problems with this guy. As I assume from the story, he's a spoilt guy with filthy rich parents and he's also Wil's employer, I'm not wrong, right? But then, how can a rich guy like Mark have anything to do with a poor guy like Wil? I mean, though they can be employer and subordinate, and their relationship is nothing more than hate, and though the gift were means of sarcasm, but giving gift? I know I don't give presents to others unless I'm close with the on a certain level (it may be it's just me). What I mean is, they must have a much more complicated relationship than just that. I mean, if Mark and Wil were to act like they did, they must have a "bond" And bonds aren't just happened to exist, they must be formed through some set of circumstances, right? So I think they should have a more deep background, a backstory of some sort to lead them to be like this. Something goes like: Wil and Mark were raised in the same orphanage, they were best friends, but then Mark's family, which turns out to be the richest in the area, found their long-lost son, which then led Wil to turn his back on Mark - something like that, or anything else you can think of. I want to see to see that backstory part which is now still missing in your story.


About Jack:

Spoiler:
How many times do you go to a bar without money and then a complete stranger pay for your drink? Not many... That's what I think... I mean, helping out others is, of course, what Christmas is all about, I agree, but I would rather they have met in a different situation, where Jack can help Wil out in other way. Even providing that it CAN happen, I don't think paying for a beer packs much of a punch in Wil's mind, I mean, I don't think it can be that influential to make some guy take home some girl on the street... When you think about it, you see, pay for a beer and take home a complete stranger... I hope you can get what I mean up till now...


About Wilfred and Claire:

Spoiler:
As I have stated before, also, last time, the way Wil is taking someone he has just met on the street sounds really unbelievable. Maybe you wrote that to elevate the touching level of the piece, which I guess kinda works, but still, I don't anyone would do that, not even some rich humanitarian, let alone some seriously-broke guy who can barely take of himself. But it's seriously touched my heart. Then again, you might to work on it to make it a little more bit "real". And also, this guy is really weak, both emotionally and physically. I mean, when I read this, he was falling to the ground all over, I was like "It's this guy for real?". I think we don't fall to the ground these days, which you can only see that in manga now. Even if you can do that now, I think they would only do that when there's a climax mental breakdown because of some truths or something, which I think all the situations in the piece failed to reach that much... And also the way he hug Claire. I don't really know about others, but we don't hug that much here, but I don't think he can hug her so dearly but so casually like that. I mean, when I read that last part of the story, the image I got in my head makes me think that Wil had known Claire for a lifetime already, not just some girl he has just met. Claire was, well, totally fine with me, nothing I would change about her.


Also things about the setting of the story, too:

Spoiler:
I would rather had it more carefully described, but I guess it's still fine if it's not. But I do have some other problems. First, the orphanage. It must be somewhere in town, yeah? But then, it's strange he doesn't visit often. One time he finally decide to, then it turns out to be nowhere to be seen, that's just sad... One more important thing. You set the story in the Christmas night, right? Of course that's when people get out of the house and do something outside, so the streets have got to be packed, right? However, when I read the story, I don't think there's anyone at all on the streets, which is extremely weird. Somewhere near a bar must be crowded. Or is it that everyone is so frigid to each other that they don't even care if there's a guy fainting in front of them? Not just that scene, throughout the whole story, I can't see almost no one else apart from the four main characters, and that's not good.


Thanks if you have read to this point. Though I have said much, and I'm sorry if I sounds harsh, but I still fully enjoyed it and I think it's touching and the piece just speak to me. You have definitely made it better. And I just want you to know that, the whole thing is written with a big "IF I WERE YOU" on top, so yeah, everything is my subjective opinions, you can discard this thing, hahah.

Well, be sure to reply if you read this, 'kay?








WOAH THATS LONG. Okay i will address every point 1 by 1.

Grammatical errors? Really? My personal editor is better than me at this, really.

About Mark:
Yes, there was supposed to be backstory but i sort of left it up to the imagination of the reader. You can do that sometimes, but if you want a backstory i might write one. (Also, in my new story, the newspaper article were these 2 guys)

About Jack:
I was betting on the willingness of a reader's suspension of disbelief.
Like, they would suspend their "common sense" for just a bit to get past it. Well, it was originally a rushed story, you can't expect perfect groundwork anyway. But imagine this: A man who has betrayed and been betrayed his whole life, never got kindness since he was young, and is just a loner. I'm sure any act of kindness might impact him, and he's a good guy at heart, so he just needed a "push".

Wil & Claire:
What can i say? Suspension of Disbelief. Also, if it made the story more "touching" i'm definitely fine with that. You know, i think you have the potential to be a professional critic. Yes, as i mentioned above as well, imagine a guy under those kind of circumstances. If you wanted backstory maybe i could write one to clear up holes. Strangely enough, my "editor" commented on those things as well! Except she thought that the way he hugged her was..."Pedo-ish" according to her.

Setting:
He's a busy guy trying to get food on his table by working 24/7 sound familiar? Also, it's because his employers got closed down, that's why he has so much free time. Hey, i dunno bout there but around where i live, it's pretty damn quiet unless you live near the city, and i think the setting i put was...in a smaller town, i think? besides, i explained it with the opening sentence, that they were privately celebrating.


Maybe some of my counter-points might have been weak, especially that suspension of disbelief part, i don't even know if i got my definition right =.=. But hopefully you understand what i mean?
0
AssasinZAssasin wrote...
WOAH THATS LONG. Okay i will address every point 1 by 1.

Grammatical errors? Really? My personal editor is better than me at this, really.

About Mark:
Yes, there was supposed to be backstory but i sort of left it up to the imagination of the reader. You can do that sometimes, but if you want a backstory i might write one. (Also, in my new story, the newspaper article were these 2 guys)

About Jack:
I was betting on the willingness of a reader's suspension of disbelief.
Like, they would suspend their "common sense" for just a bit to get past it. Well, it was originally a rushed story, you can't expect perfect groundwork anyway. But imagine this: A man who has betrayed and been betrayed his whole life, never got kindness since he was young, and is just a loner. I'm sure any act of kindness might impact him, and he's a good guy at heart, so he just needed a "push".

Wil & Claire:
What can i say? Suspension of Disbelief. Also, if it made the story more "touching" i'm definitely fine with that. You know, i think you have the potential to be a professional critic. Yes, as i mentioned above as well, imagine a guy under those kind of circumstances. If you wanted backstory maybe i could write one to clear up holes. Strangely enough, my "editor" commented on those things as well! Except she thought that the way he hugged her was..."Pedo-ish" according to her.

Setting:
He's a busy guy trying to get food on his table by working 24/7 sound familiar? Also, it's because his employers got closed down, that's why he has so much free time. Hey, i dunno bout there but around where i live, it's pretty damn quiet unless you live near the city, and i think the setting i put was...in a smaller town, i think? besides, i explained it with the opening sentence, that they were privately celebrating.


Maybe some of my counter-points might have been weak, especially that suspension of disbelief part, i don't even know if i got my definition right =.=. But hopefully you understand what i mean?


Yeah, of course everybody has their own taste in their story, and of course I can't do anything about that. Those were just things that I would do to the story, if it was mine, which is not. You wrote it and I read it. And I enjoyed it. And I can understand everything you said, and of course, I am totally okay with it, it's your story anyway.

There's just one thing. I live in a big city, so I know we go out on Christmas. I don't know about it in small towns, but I think they would be very close to each other, so they also go out to celebrate together? But the Mark guy, isn't he the son of the richest company around? I find it strange to have a big-shot company in a small town. Anyway, just saying. You are the one who decide it.

Oh, and, I don't really like being called "critic" :( It make me sound like some guy who don't actually really good at stories or have super intellect about it but like to judge people =.= Anyway, I just like to express what I think, don't think me of an pro or anything =.=
0
AssasinZAssasin Not Hentai Protagonist
Dawn_of_Dark wrote...
AssasinZAssasin wrote...
WOAH THATS LONG. Okay i will address every point 1 by 1.

Grammatical errors? Really? My personal editor is better than me at this, really.

About Mark:
Yes, there was supposed to be backstory but i sort of left it up to the imagination of the reader. You can do that sometimes, but if you want a backstory i might write one. (Also, in my new story, the newspaper article were these 2 guys)

About Jack:
I was betting on the willingness of a reader's suspension of disbelief.
Like, they would suspend their "common sense" for just a bit to get past it. Well, it was originally a rushed story, you can't expect perfect groundwork anyway. But imagine this: A man who has betrayed and been betrayed his whole life, never got kindness since he was young, and is just a loner. I'm sure any act of kindness might impact him, and he's a good guy at heart, so he just needed a "push".

Wil & Claire:
What can i say? Suspension of Disbelief. Also, if it made the story more "touching" i'm definitely fine with that. You know, i think you have the potential to be a professional critic. Yes, as i mentioned above as well, imagine a guy under those kind of circumstances. If you wanted backstory maybe i could write one to clear up holes. Strangely enough, my "editor" commented on those things as well! Except she thought that the way he hugged her was..."Pedo-ish" according to her.

Setting:
He's a busy guy trying to get food on his table by working 24/7 sound familiar? Also, it's because his employers got closed down, that's why he has so much free time. Hey, i dunno bout there but around where i live, it's pretty damn quiet unless you live near the city, and i think the setting i put was...in a smaller town, i think? besides, i explained it with the opening sentence, that they were privately celebrating.


Maybe some of my counter-points might have been weak, especially that suspension of disbelief part, i don't even know if i got my definition right =.=. But hopefully you understand what i mean?


Yeah, of course everybody has their own taste in their story, and of course I can't do anything about that. Those were just things that I would do to the story, if it was mine, which is not. You wrote it and I read it. And I enjoyed it. And I can understand everything you said, and of course, I am totally okay with it, it's your story anyway.

There's just one thing. I live in a big city, so I know we go out on Christmas. I don't know about it in small towns, but I think they would be very close to each other, so they also go out to celebrate together? But the Mark guy, isn't he the son of the richest company around? I find it strange to have a big-shot company in a small town. Anyway, just saying. You are the one who decide it.

Oh, and, I don't really like being called "critic" :( It make me sound like some guy who don't actually really good at stories or have super intellect about it but like to judge people =.= Anyway, I just like to express what I think, don't think me of an pro or anything =.=


I mean, if his company was super big it'd be all over the damn place, be it in small or big places? I mean, i do appreciate your reviews though! Small towns always gave me the impression of a more private place though, i never know.
0
AssasinZAssasin wrote...
I mean, if his company was super big it'd be all over the damn place, be it in small or big places? I mean, i do appreciate your reviews though! Small towns always gave me the impression of a more private place though, i never know.


But I think they don't USUALLY open big companies in small towns?

Glad to be of help!

...

Or am I?

Spoiler:
Forum Image: https://www.fakku.net/image-404/images/1368874-MEG7DJE.png


I don't know, too, but after playing so many games, I think they are usually close with each other, you know, like neighbors? I think they would get more chances to talk to each other and do stuff together than folks in big cities?
0
AssasinZAssasin Not Hentai Protagonist
Dawn_of_Dark wrote...
AssasinZAssasin wrote...
I mean, if his company was super big it'd be all over the damn place, be it in small or big places? I mean, i do appreciate your reviews though! Small towns always gave me the impression of a more private place though, i never know.


But I think they don't USUALLY open big companies in small towns?

Glad to be of help!

...

Or am I?

Spoiler:
Forum Image: https://www.fakku.net/image-404/images/1368874-MEG7DJE.png


I don't know, too, but after playing so many games, I think they are usually close with each other, you know, like neighbors? I think they would get more chances to talk to each other and do stuff together than folks in big cities?


Whuts with the Pikachu...
Well, i suppose this company is a big as huge ass conglomerates so...It just opens all over the damn place.

Well, yeah okay, how about the places where the main guy visits are the "not so good" parts of town, where people don't really go to visit? Besides, i think he was out pretty late at night...
Pages 12Next