[Winter Contest Entry 2012] The Perfect Companion
0
Cinia Pacifica
Ojou-sama Writer
It's imperfect, hence it's perfection.
I present to what little readers I have:
According to this, it's 1938 words.
I present to what little readers I have:
Spoiler:
According to this, it's 1938 words.
0
niiiice :3 I can tell that you spent quite some time elaborating your work and polishing for improvements. I honestly enjoyed reading it. Keep up the good work, Rice-chan
0
Cinia Pacifica
Ojou-sama Writer
chibi FAKKU girl wrote...
niiiice :3 I can tell that you spent quite some time elaborating your work and polishing for improvements. I honestly enjoyed reading it. Keep up the good work, Rice-chan
*Rise
Yeah I did, like 5 hours only... I wish my laziness died out earlier lol. I'd have had more time to make it better.
And yes, the title of this work derived from 'The Golden Companion' story that I wrote for you.
high_time wrote...
well that was kind of expectedSpoiler:
NTR was never intended, and nor did the guy actually got stolen.... well, the devilish girl tried, lol.
He simply seeks out alternatives to getting laid and all.
The wife is no yandere (it wasn't intended either). She lacks most of the emotions that human beings harbors. Jealousy for example. She simply feared that she won't be able to go to heaven with her husband after he dies *normally*. She thought that her husband would only belong to her, once and for all, once they reach heaven and start living there together.
But all that didn't seem possible when he started doing all that behind her back. God would deem it sinful.
0
leonard267
FAKKU Non-Writer
A good read and I mean it. How on earth did you complete this within 5 hours?!
0
Aai
FAKKU Ass Master
Needed more character detail I think, put a little too much time in scenery.
That is just my opinion though, I try to fit all I can in short stories.
3/5 = Grammar
3/5 = Concept
3/5 = Conclusion
Average scores by yours truly.
That is just my opinion though, I try to fit all I can in short stories.
3/5 = Grammar
3/5 = Concept
3/5 = Conclusion
Average scores by yours truly.
0
FGRaptor
FAKKU Writer
I hate to admit that I did not finish reading this. I read about 1/3 I'd say, the beginning and the end. So if you want to you can fully ignore me here, but I will post my feedback anyway. The reason why I stopped reading was that I found the language too flowery. I couldn't really get past that. With this I mean the descriptive parts and the imagery, not the dialogue which is pretty good I think. It's a bit sad because I like the way your story pans out, but that barrier and then the slow start stopped me from getting too far.
As I said though it's a good concept from what I read, and I thought I would comment anyway to say why I didn't read it whole.
As I said though it's a good concept from what I read, and I thought I would comment anyway to say why I didn't read it whole.
0
You could make it as good as usual, Rise (or Cinia, of you prefer it). I did enjoy reading the whole thing.
What I like most about this one is the usage of word, every word is worth being there in is own rights. Too flowery? Guess I like that, and I think that what makes you different from others. But, in the grammar aspect, if we look closely, there are some part that's wrong. And there are also some parts which have a full end, instead of a comma, which would be more correct.
The story, is quite intriguing. I personally don't like blood, especially when the girl is the killer, and ESPECIALLY when she is an angel (It still looks like a typical yandere to me) =.= But I guess it's nothing too significant. I also didn't like how you suddenly become so focus in depicting her smile in the first part, too detailed and too much - it's redundant, it kinda smothers readers. I like how smooth it was when you go from one paragraph to another, like Sora said. While it's good, but the concept to me, wasn't all that unique - it's fairly ordinary, with the angel added. And I don't like the ending either. I don't watch lots of yandere stuffs, but I can't get why a guy got stabbed by an angel, and he's okay with that? I mean, he's going to die! How can a person accept the fact so easily? Again, not much yandere experience :D
So in conclusion, yours was quite good and all, but it's not perfect. Guess you really did spend only 5 hours working on this, huh? I mean, it struck with good impression at first glance, but when we read it again, closely, you can still find some errors. But looks like yours going to win anyway. Well, I really hope you will bring more amazing pieces of story in the future!
What I like most about this one is the usage of word, every word is worth being there in is own rights. Too flowery? Guess I like that, and I think that what makes you different from others. But, in the grammar aspect, if we look closely, there are some part that's wrong. And there are also some parts which have a full end, instead of a comma, which would be more correct.
The story, is quite intriguing. I personally don't like blood, especially when the girl is the killer, and ESPECIALLY when she is an angel (It still looks like a typical yandere to me) =.= But I guess it's nothing too significant. I also didn't like how you suddenly become so focus in depicting her smile in the first part, too detailed and too much - it's redundant, it kinda smothers readers. I like how smooth it was when you go from one paragraph to another, like Sora said. While it's good, but the concept to me, wasn't all that unique - it's fairly ordinary, with the angel added. And I don't like the ending either. I don't watch lots of yandere stuffs, but I can't get why a guy got stabbed by an angel, and he's okay with that? I mean, he's going to die! How can a person accept the fact so easily? Again, not much yandere experience :D
So in conclusion, yours was quite good and all, but it's not perfect. Guess you really did spend only 5 hours working on this, huh? I mean, it struck with good impression at first glance, but when we read it again, closely, you can still find some errors. But looks like yours going to win anyway. Well, I really hope you will bring more amazing pieces of story in the future!
0
Livided
FAKKU Writer
I think any critism I had for this story has already been voiced, no need to repeat it.
Overal it was a good story though and I felt a lot of emotion coming from it, was an interesting experience. ^^
Overal it was a good story though and I felt a lot of emotion coming from it, was an interesting experience. ^^
0
Lughost
the Lugoat
Not gonna lie, I did not like it and you won't like me by the end of this post .
Where to begin...
Where to begin...
Spoiler:
0
Honestly, I didn't enjoy reading this. The characters are too plastic, the situation becomes a mess, and I found many grammatical errors that distracted me. It would be fine if it was a comedic hentai with some corny one-liners, but it's not.
0
Meh.
Meh.
...Yes.
YES.
YES!
YEEEEEESSSSSSS!!!
YYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEESSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
I WANT TO SHOUT FROM THE MOUNTAINTOPS MY OVERWHELMING APPROVAL OF THIS STORY.
This gets my vote.
P.S. Fuck your shit Rice, I don't forget.
Meh.
...Yes.
YES.
YES!
YEEEEEESSSSSSS!!!
YYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEESSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
I WANT TO SHOUT FROM THE MOUNTAINTOPS MY OVERWHELMING APPROVAL OF THIS STORY.
This gets my vote.
P.S. Fuck your shit Rice, I don't forget.
0
Xenon
FAKKU Writer
This is a pretty amazing piece. You should be very proud of it. Your knowledge of English has improved and grown a lot and this piece reflects that. There are some confusing changes of tense in inappropriate manners and a ton of errors, but this is certainly your best piece to date. I am very proud of you for this and I intentionally went hard on you because of all the progress you’ve made.
FYI: I am an editor by nature. I read word-for-word and I pick up almost every little thing. So, the only way I can express my corrections is by directly reposting your story. Additions are in red, comments are in dark red, removals are strike-through. Here you are.
FYI: I am an editor by nature. I read word-for-word and I pick up almost every little thing. So, the only way I can express my corrections is by directly reposting your story. Additions are in red, comments are in dark red, removals are strike-through. Here you are.
Spoiler: