NeoStriker wrote...
Kaimax wrote...
First and foremost, what makes a ERO have high quality (example a 5 star rating)? What's the measurement?
The easiest is the amount, which is countable and is not subjective to any opinion. How the scenario and the writing is brought into the ERO scenes is a whole different section, which obviously falls into writing and scenario criteria.
So are you saying how many porno pictures there are in a visual novel should influence how it's overall rating is? So a visual novel with over a 1,000 porno pictures, regardless of the drawing style and quality, as well as the scene that accompanies it, gets maybe 10 stars, with 1 star in everything else. It gets an A. How is that an accurate judgement?
you're completely out of topic, I'm focusing only the ERO rating as a
SINGLE Rating, not the overall rating of a VN. Yet you keep on, trying to combine this with Writing and Scenarios.
NeoStriker wrote...
Kaimax wrote...
and
how would you know that a VN with High amount of ERO "doesn't have writing/scenario quality" if you have never played one.
I have played a visual novel before. I have played plenty of visual novels, with porn and no porn.
No, what I meant, have you ever played those ones currently one the list I posted that have "5 stars"? It's obvious that you have never played these "kinds" of VNs and only stick to translated VNs.
NeoStriker wrote...
Kaimax wrote...
you're basically now discriminating VNs based on the amount of ERO.
Discriminating...? So is that what all visual novels should be about? Just the porn? Like in my above example, if a visual novel just had plenty of porno pictures, should it be considered a masterpiece?
Like I said you never played one
specifically, none of the translated ones has this.
Try to play France Shoujo/Amatsukaze/Prima Stella first
NeoStriker wrote...
Kaimax wrote...
And did you know that visual Novels is a term made by the western community to make things convenient, and by lumping together all the styles of the "original" VN media.
To the point that a "obviously clear" Hentai game was rated bad just because it was "sexual oriented".
I consider porno visual novels a different genre, and I grade it thusly, much like how I grade a horror visual novel on it's realism and horror. If you're going to work porn into a visual novel, then you should make it work. Cross Channel's porn worked because of the main protagonist. I could see why the porn and his ero habits worked.
Elaborate "Make porn work". There's no legitimate measurement on how the "porn" works, it's clearly your opinion.
Final question, How many VNs that you actually played?
Your claims are not vaild until you play them for your self, not just assuming things just because you have the idea that [b]High amount of Ero = Not a good VN, I rather buy a playboy.
and finally
The List is used as reference, it's not a fact, yet you keep denying it as it's a written fact.