The Jesus wrote...
You're gonna get me started with this again...
The main problem with Ikki Tousen is that the adaptation of Romance of the Three Kingdoms into that type format results in a very esoteric product. Before I watched Ikki Tousen, all I had known was what I read about the Three Kingdoms and the later Han, along with what I gathered from Dynasty Warriors, which Koei took plenty of creative liberties in making.
As far as I'm concerned, the Achilles heel of Ikki Tousen has to be the number of episodes. I mean, its difficult to capture any aspect of a Three Kingdoms related story, no matter how "different" it is, in 13 episodes. I'm not sure exactly how the 13 episode limit affected the staff's approach in the production process, but its obvious that the final product suffered. Despite the fact that the first series or season, whatever, was pretty fucking bad, I enjoyed it. Dragon Destiny, with the development of the characters, a nice twist on the events that occurred in RotTK, and obviously, a greater focus on Kanu, worked out really well. As for Great Guardians, it was an original plot and, in that sense, it had its ups and downs. You can't say it fails based on the story alone, only because its like a tangent.
Obviously, its very difficult to capture the essence of Ikki Tousen overall, seeing as how its been a while since I've watched it and I'm fucking trashed. The thing that's really important is the subtlety. Most people miss a lot of shit and because of that there's a complete lack of depth, but it actually does create an awesome story, even in the beginning. You can't look at the characters as the warriors that they represent. Hakufu is the incarnation of Sun Ce, Ryuubi is Liu Bei, Kanu is Guan Yu, and so on. Where it gets interesting is that they possess their spirits and share their fates, but they're still themselves and because of that they can either accept the fate that's dictated by history, or they can struggle against it. The fact that the majority of the characters are female, but possess the spirits of male warriors actually makes that even more interesting.
Really, what I'm trying to say is that when you watch Ikki Tousen, you have to keep an open mind. Of course there's the fan service and you can't and most likely don't want to avoid it, but its more than violent bitches beating the hell out of each other and getting their clothes ripped off. If you noticed, Chou-un's clothes are never ripped or damaged when she fights. Considering that she's the incarnation of Zhao Yun, who according to some accounts, was never scratched let alone wounded in battle, can kind of jog a little curiosity about the more obscure aspects of the series.
Now, there's no guarantee that I'm completely wrong in what I'm saying because, as I said, I'm drunk, but I'm a fan of Ikki Tousen. People are so ready to attack it and that makes me all the more ready to look at it in depth and shit just to, you know, shut them the fuck up. Its hard to just say to all the haters, "chill the fuck out with all the hating and take a fucking look beyond all the fucking fan service," but that's something I'm working at.
I'm sure some people think I'm fucking nuts for being this into it, but whatever.
No, not nuts - open minded and informed.
Even drunk that's a good thumbnail of the basiscs that this anime is based on...not something I knew before watching this series the first time but something that does add to my current viewing experience, thankyou
The Jesus
I suppose it still in the long run comes down to enjoyment, some people will enjoy a series on what ever level they are watching it on, and maybe even get some extra insight from it...and others will just not enjoy that same series.