[Locked] Futanari and futa-on-female shouldn't be tagged yuri.

I would have to agree that futa-on-female isn't yuri...

Also, a strap-on does not equal futa...

It's still a girl on a girl action, so it's still Yuri.

Yuri and Yaoi isn't about what "genitals" that you use, but the gender itself.
A futanari is still a girl despite a new extra genital.

Unless that futa is actually a tranny that got a boob job.

I disagree. It's still girl on girl so it should still be classified as Yuri.

Like this one "futa" doujin by Insert?

s/a2361473bf/352651-7

Yes, that's not Yuri, because of those reasons I posted.

If there's a lot of emphasis on their female qualities (or if they have both sets of genitals), might count...

Dickgirl should be seperated from futanari. that is two different things.

[color=#2e1a6b]I think there are 2 possible ways to tag this
Option A:


[color=#2e1a6b]Option B:


[color=#2e1a6b]The advantage of option A is that it distinguishes the different type of futa pairing; you could identify if it's futa x girl or futa x guy.

The advantage of option B is that real yuri will still be tagged. A lot of futa starts out with real yuri, then transitions into futa. Option B can describe the existence of both, unlike option A. Another advantage to option B is that really complicated futa scenarios are easy to tag; just slap a futa tag and you're done, whereas option A might have "futa + yaoi + Yuri" all in the same manga.

I like the way Lelouch24 put it in option A. it seems to be the most discriptive and accurate way to tag futa related.

That is how we currently do things... The first link was tagged as Futa and Yuri, can't be any confusion there so people wont accidentally run into it. Just have to read all the tags before you look for fap material.

The doujins in question are considered Futa and Yuri.

As a side note, Kaimax does have authority "backing his assertions". Did the part about him being a member of our staff escape you?

It might be ambiguous, but most of the times the gender is explicitly showed in the story, and many times the characters are girls, or normal girls that got a dick with magic or something else.

I can sort of see the logic behind the yuri and yaoi tags added if only one party is futa, but if all parties involved are futa, it should have only a futa tag.

We're not, but we do get to decide what it means on our site. I thought the goal of this thread was to get something changed on Fakku, so the people you want to convince are the staff here. Kaimax is part of that authoritative group that has a say in what the word means here, so don't claim he has no authority. Why does what other sites do matter? The piece of work has girl on girl and a girl with a penis, so both things are tagged, if you dont like futa or yuri don't read it.

Buy a dictionary.

Authority (countable and uncountable; plural authorities)

1.(uncountable) The power to enforce rules or give orders. I have the authority to penalise the staff in my department, but not the authority to sack them. She lost all her respect and authority after turning up drunk to the meeting. Respect my authority!

2.(used in singular or plural form) Persons in command; specifically, government.

3.(countable) A person accepted as a source of reliable information on a subject. The world's foremost authority on orangutans.


He didn't say kaimax doesn't HAVE authority, he said FAKKU is not AN authority on the definition of terms.

you miss the point like it's your job.

But kaimax is an authority on the subject matter here on Fakku. What he said is how Jacob feels and that's what the user is trying to change. Kaimax wasnt speaking for the hentai community as a whole but for Fakku. Seems like you missed my point, try not to take things soo personally shag.

I never understood why anyone care that a mango or douchen need to be label to this tag or that tag. Does it really matter if a dick girl is yuri if she bangs a dickless girl? I can see why tagging a futa on futa into futa because well they both has a pee pee.. still she has a vagina too. I'm not going the full professor with the xx/xy/xxy/xyy thing but.. why care.. it's usually mention has a futa or something description 'yo she has a penis and vagina' on the statement.. usually.