1. Forums
  3. Incoherent Babbling
Post Reply

WAIFU GAME XI: Discussion

Pages 45464748495051
0
BagMan
11 years ago
Zandorf wrote...
Sabers Praetor wrote...
TheBookie wrote...
Zandorf wrote...
Revelation wrote...
From the lovely ladies in the Occult Research Club set:
Asia, Akeno, Rias, Koneko, Xenovia I claim the right to a sixth waifu.


I don't know if this has been talked about yet, but the "Ladies of the Occult Research Club" set isn't complete yet, unless we are talking about just the anime.
Spoiler:
In the light novels, there are three other people that join the club, but the anime hasn't caught up to that point yet.

The other three are:
Rossweisse
Irina Shidou
and Ravel Phenex

And even if you went with the ladies of Rias' chess pieces, you'd be missing Rossweisse, who is Rias' second rook.


I could argue its the set that are students at the school and are of the "chess" pieces.

There is not such thing as an Ace in chess and Rossweisse is a teacher

and Ravel is technically a student but if you go off the basis of the Anime she wouldnt be in the ORC, yet

If we go strictly based on Season 1 of the Anime - we have collected everyone and then some, since Xenovia was introduced in season 2

And rossweisse hasnt been included just yet (or i dont believe so)

regardless it's up to ruling by pumpjack - if so my claim would be invalid.



Well as pump just said go by whats recent


For this case, it isn't just about what's recent. It's more of if you have to take the LN into consideration, even though the anime is so far behind. And to be completely honest, the LN was more recently updated than the anime.


I think Jack's rule about recent things is precisely to prevent this kind of thing. essentially the medium that has gotten the least far in terms of story almost always takes precedence.
0
sakabato24 World Warrior
11 years ago
Looky-tan wrote...
I shall now marry/claim, Kotori Minami from Love Live! School Idol Project.
Spoiler:

Forum Image: http://i1140.photobucket.com/albums/n566/Lookynyan/Love%20Live/Kotori2-1.jpg


Yay~! Another brave soul devoting themselves to the world of Love Live! Idols~
0
TheBookie King of Red
11 years ago
Zandorf wrote...

For this case, it isn't just about what's recent. It's more of if you have to take the LN into consideration, even though the anime is so far behind. And to be completely honest, the LN was more recently updated than the anime.[/spoil]


Well it's all up to pumpjack. The set of Anime Season 1 is complete.

In season 2 it would only be Irina in question because the other 2 have not turned yet...or maybe my memory is wrong.

If we need all the girls of the ORC as far as the LN goes then so be it.

But then that means a lot of other sets can be questioned that have already been claimed under the same argument of what is "recent"

You still have a valid point regardless, so we'll see what the ruling is.
1
PumpJack McGee
11 years ago
BagMan wrote...
Zandorf wrote...
Sabers Praetor wrote...
TheBookie wrote...
Zandorf wrote...
Revelation wrote...
From the lovely ladies in the Occult Research Club set:
Asia, Akeno, Rias, Koneko, Xenovia I claim the right to a sixth waifu.


I don't know if this has been talked about yet, but the "Ladies of the Occult Research Club" set isn't complete yet, unless we are talking about just the anime.
Spoiler:
In the light novels, there are three other people that join the club, but the anime hasn't caught up to that point yet.

The other three are:
Rossweisse
Irina Shidou
and Ravel Phenex

And even if you went with the ladies of Rias' chess pieces, you'd be missing Rossweisse, who is Rias' second rook.


I could argue its the set that are students at the school and are of the "chess" pieces.

There is not such thing as an Ace in chess and Rossweisse is a teacher

and Ravel is technically a student but if you go off the basis of the Anime she wouldnt be in the ORC, yet

If we go strictly based on Season 1 of the Anime - we have collected everyone and then some, since Xenovia was introduced in season 2

And rossweisse hasnt been included just yet (or i dont believe so)

regardless it's up to ruling by pumpjack - if so my claim would be invalid.



Well as pump just said go by whats recent


For this case, it isn't just about what's recent. It's more of if you have to take the LN into consideration, even though the anime is so far behind. And to be completely honest, the LN was more recently updated than the anime.


I think Jack's rule about recent things is precisely to prevent this kind of thing. essentially the medium that has gotten the least far in terms of story almost always takes precedence.


Yes and no.

The main reason why I'm going with most recent iterations is because- for the most part- it's somewhat unreasonable to expect everyone to have watched/played/read all of a franchise across all its mediums. It's the distinction between casual, hardcore, and diehard fans.

And so- by going with the most recent incarnation of a series- it allows for more people to jump in on a potential set, since more people would know of it.

I will admit that I failed to take into account the chronological differences that would affect potential sets. One medium may be further along into the story, and thus have different members join/leave/die/temporary alliance/etc. of a particular set.

In which case- we'll just go by the most recent. At least for this game.


And in which I am incredibly thankful that very few people are making claims in western media (stuff like the X-Men would be fucking hellish to try and sort out).
0
Zandorf
11 years ago
PumpJack McGee wrote...
Spoiler:
BagMan wrote...
Zandorf wrote...
Sabers Praetor wrote...
TheBookie wrote...
Zandorf wrote...
Revelation wrote...
From the lovely ladies in the Occult Research Club set:
Asia, Akeno, Rias, Koneko, Xenovia I claim the right to a sixth waifu.


I don't know if this has been talked about yet, but the "Ladies of the Occult Research Club" set isn't complete yet, unless we are talking about just the anime.
Spoiler:
In the light novels, there are three other people that join the club, but the anime hasn't caught up to that point yet.

The other three are:
Rossweisse
Irina Shidou
and Ravel Phenex

And even if you went with the ladies of Rias' chess pieces, you'd be missing Rossweisse, who is Rias' second rook.


I could argue its the set that are students at the school and are of the "chess" pieces.

There is not such thing as an Ace in chess and Rossweisse is a teacher

and Ravel is technically a student but if you go off the basis of the Anime she wouldnt be in the ORC, yet

If we go strictly based on Season 1 of the Anime - we have collected everyone and then some, since Xenovia was introduced in season 2

And rossweisse hasnt been included just yet (or i dont believe so)

regardless it's up to ruling by pumpjack - if so my claim would be invalid.



Well as pump just said go by whats recent


For this case, it isn't just about what's recent. It's more of if you have to take the LN into consideration, even though the anime is so far behind. And to be completely honest, the LN was more recently updated than the anime.


I think Jack's rule about recent things is precisely to prevent this kind of thing. essentially the medium that has gotten the least far in terms of story almost always takes precedence.


Yes and no.

The main reason why I'm going with most recent iterations is because- for the most part- it's somewhat unreasonable to expect everyone to have watched/played/read all of a franchise across all its mediums. It's the distinction between casual, hardcore, and diehard fans.

And so- by going with the most recent incarnation of a series- it allows for more people to jump in on a potential set, since more people would know of it.

I will admit that I failed to take into account the chronological differences that would affect potential sets. One medium may be further along into the story, and thus have different members join/leave/die/temporary alliance/etc. of a particular set.

In which case- we'll just go by the most recent. At least for this game.


And in which I am incredibly thankful that very few people are making claims in western media (stuff like the X-Men would be fucking hellish to try and sort out).


So, do we take this as you saying the set is complete based off of the anime? Or...?
0
PumpJack McGee
11 years ago
Zandorf wrote...
PumpJack McGee wrote...
Spoiler:
BagMan wrote...
Zandorf wrote...
Sabers Praetor wrote...
TheBookie wrote...
Zandorf wrote...
Revelation wrote...
From the lovely ladies in the Occult Research Club set:
Asia, Akeno, Rias, Koneko, Xenovia I claim the right to a sixth waifu.


I don't know if this has been talked about yet, but the "Ladies of the Occult Research Club" set isn't complete yet, unless we are talking about just the anime.
Spoiler:
In the light novels, there are three other people that join the club, but the anime hasn't caught up to that point yet.

The other three are:
Rossweisse
Irina Shidou
and Ravel Phenex

And even if you went with the ladies of Rias' chess pieces, you'd be missing Rossweisse, who is Rias' second rook.


I could argue its the set that are students at the school and are of the "chess" pieces.

There is not such thing as an Ace in chess and Rossweisse is a teacher

and Ravel is technically a student but if you go off the basis of the Anime she wouldnt be in the ORC, yet

If we go strictly based on Season 1 of the Anime - we have collected everyone and then some, since Xenovia was introduced in season 2

And rossweisse hasnt been included just yet (or i dont believe so)

regardless it's up to ruling by pumpjack - if so my claim would be invalid.



Well as pump just said go by whats recent


For this case, it isn't just about what's recent. It's more of if you have to take the LN into consideration, even though the anime is so far behind. And to be completely honest, the LN was more recently updated than the anime.


I think Jack's rule about recent things is precisely to prevent this kind of thing. essentially the medium that has gotten the least far in terms of story almost always takes precedence.


Yes and no.

The main reason why I'm going with most recent iterations is because- for the most part- it's somewhat unreasonable to expect everyone to have watched/played/read all of a franchise across all its mediums. It's the distinction between casual, hardcore, and diehard fans.

And so- by going with the most recent incarnation of a series- it allows for more people to jump in on a potential set, since more people would know of it.

I will admit that I failed to take into account the chronological differences that would affect potential sets. One medium may be further along into the story, and thus have different members join/leave/die/temporary alliance/etc. of a particular set.

In which case- we'll just go by the most recent. At least for this game.


And in which I am incredibly thankful that very few people are making claims in western media (stuff like the X-Men would be fucking hellish to try and sort out).


So, do we take this as you saying the set is complete based off of the anime? Or...?


What does your heart tell you?
0
TheBookie King of Red
11 years ago
PumpJack McGee wrote...
Zandorf wrote...
PumpJack McGee wrote...
Spoiler:
BagMan wrote...
Zandorf wrote...
Sabers Praetor wrote...
TheBookie wrote...
Zandorf wrote...
Revelation wrote...
From the lovely ladies in the Occult Research Club set:
Asia, Akeno, Rias, Koneko, Xenovia I claim the right to a sixth waifu.


I don't know if this has been talked about yet, but the "Ladies of the Occult Research Club" set isn't complete yet, unless we are talking about just the anime.
Spoiler:
In the light novels, there are three other people that join the club, but the anime hasn't caught up to that point yet.

The other three are:
Rossweisse
Irina Shidou
and Ravel Phenex

And even if you went with the ladies of Rias' chess pieces, you'd be missing Rossweisse, who is Rias' second rook.


I could argue its the set that are students at the school and are of the "chess" pieces.

There is not such thing as an Ace in chess and Rossweisse is a teacher

and Ravel is technically a student but if you go off the basis of the Anime she wouldnt be in the ORC, yet

If we go strictly based on Season 1 of the Anime - we have collected everyone and then some, since Xenovia was introduced in season 2

And rossweisse hasnt been included just yet (or i dont believe so)

regardless it's up to ruling by pumpjack - if so my claim would be invalid.



Well as pump just said go by whats recent


For this case, it isn't just about what's recent. It's more of if you have to take the LN into consideration, even though the anime is so far behind. And to be completely honest, the LN was more recently updated than the anime.


I think Jack's rule about recent things is precisely to prevent this kind of thing. essentially the medium that has gotten the least far in terms of story almost always takes precedence.


Yes and no.

The main reason why I'm going with most recent iterations is because- for the most part- it's somewhat unreasonable to expect everyone to have watched/played/read all of a franchise across all its mediums. It's the distinction between casual, hardcore, and diehard fans.

And so- by going with the most recent incarnation of a series- it allows for more people to jump in on a potential set, since more people would know of it.

I will admit that I failed to take into account the chronological differences that would affect potential sets. One medium may be further along into the story, and thus have different members join/leave/die/temporary alliance/etc. of a particular set.

In which case- we'll just go by the most recent. At least for this game.


And in which I am incredibly thankful that very few people are making claims in western media (stuff like the X-Men would be fucking hellish to try and sort out).


So, do we take this as you saying the set is complete based off of the anime? Or...?


What does your heart tell you?


My heart tells me.....I want tacos.....

but I would vote for anime since I doubt any of the other people who claimed in the set are up to date fully on the LN.
0
Zandorf
11 years ago
PumpJack McGee wrote...
Zandorf wrote...
PumpJack McGee wrote...
Spoiler:
BagMan wrote...
Zandorf wrote...
Sabers Praetor wrote...
TheBookie wrote...
Zandorf wrote...
Revelation wrote...
From the lovely ladies in the Occult Research Club set:
Asia, Akeno, Rias, Koneko, Xenovia I claim the right to a sixth waifu.


I don't know if this has been talked about yet, but the "Ladies of the Occult Research Club" set isn't complete yet, unless we are talking about just the anime.
Spoiler:
In the light novels, there are three other people that join the club, but the anime hasn't caught up to that point yet.

The other three are:
Rossweisse
Irina Shidou
and Ravel Phenex

And even if you went with the ladies of Rias' chess pieces, you'd be missing Rossweisse, who is Rias' second rook.


I could argue its the set that are students at the school and are of the "chess" pieces.

There is not such thing as an Ace in chess and Rossweisse is a teacher

and Ravel is technically a student but if you go off the basis of the Anime she wouldnt be in the ORC, yet

If we go strictly based on Season 1 of the Anime - we have collected everyone and then some, since Xenovia was introduced in season 2

And rossweisse hasnt been included just yet (or i dont believe so)

regardless it's up to ruling by pumpjack - if so my claim would be invalid.



Well as pump just said go by whats recent


For this case, it isn't just about what's recent. It's more of if you have to take the LN into consideration, even though the anime is so far behind. And to be completely honest, the LN was more recently updated than the anime.


I think Jack's rule about recent things is precisely to prevent this kind of thing. essentially the medium that has gotten the least far in terms of story almost always takes precedence.


Yes and no.

The main reason why I'm going with most recent iterations is because- for the most part- it's somewhat unreasonable to expect everyone to have watched/played/read all of a franchise across all its mediums. It's the distinction between casual, hardcore, and diehard fans.

And so- by going with the most recent incarnation of a series- it allows for more people to jump in on a potential set, since more people would know of it.

I will admit that I failed to take into account the chronological differences that would affect potential sets. One medium may be further along into the story, and thus have different members join/leave/die/temporary alliance/etc. of a particular set.

In which case- we'll just go by the most recent. At least for this game.


And in which I am incredibly thankful that very few people are making claims in western media (stuff like the X-Men would be fucking hellish to try and sort out).


So, do we take this as you saying the set is complete based off of the anime? Or...?


What does your heart tell you?


My heart is as black as night, so it's telling me the LN. :3

But no... it's fine either way since I already have my 6th slot and didn't claim anyone from Highschool DxD. After all, I was just trying to find out if the ORC set was to be based off of the anime or LN.
0
luinthoron High Priest of Loli
11 years ago
Well, Jack has allowed various subsets too, so season 1 and 2 sets should hopefully both be okay as well.
0
Hisobuu
11 years ago
I can feel myself turning into a desperate, sixth slot whore. Damn this game is intense.
0
luinthoron High Priest of Loli
11 years ago
I haven't seen any claims from same sources as mine so far. 6th slot seems quite unlikely for me at this time. :D
0
PumpJack McGee
11 years ago
luinthoron wrote...
Well, Jack has allowed various subsets too, so season 1 and 2 sets should hopefully both be okay as well.


Mostly for series with ridiculously large casts.

Maybe I can introduce tiers.

-Panty and Stocking(2+) - Easy. +1 Waifu

-Amagami(6+) - Normal. +1Waifu. +1Reclaim next game.

-Negima(30+) - Hard. +2Waifus. +1Reclaim next game.

-Touhou(Idon'tfuckingknow+) - Expert. +3Waifus. +2Reclaims next game. NTR Capability.





I'm putting entirely too much thought into this, aren't I.
0
BagMan
11 years ago
PumpJack McGee wrote...
luinthoron wrote...
Well, Jack has allowed various subsets too, so season 1 and 2 sets should hopefully both be okay as well.


Mostly for series with ridiculously large casts.

Maybe I can introduce tiers.

-Panty and Stocking(2+) - Easy. +1 Waifu

-Amagami(6+) - Normal. +1Waifu. +1Reclaim next game.

-Negima(30+) - Hard. +2Waifus. +1Reclaim next game.

-Touhou(Idon'tfuckingknow+) - Expert. +3Waifus. +2Reclaims next game. NTR Capability.





I'm putting entirely too much thought into this, aren't I.


Definitely.
0
Zandorf
11 years ago
PumpJack McGee wrote...
-Touhou(Idon'tfuckingknow+)


Just so that you do know in the future, in alphabetical order and female only:
Spoiler:

Alice Margatroid
Aya Shameimaru
Benben Tsukumo
Byakuren Hijiri
Chen
Chiyuri Kitashirakawa
Cirno
Daiyousei
Eiki Shiki, Yamaxanadu
Eirin Yagokoro
Elis
Ellen
Elly
Flandre Scarlet
Fujiwara no Mokou
Gengetsu
Hata no Kokoro
Hatate Himekaidou
Hieda no Akyuu
Hina Kagiyama
Hong Meiling
Ichirin Kumoi
Iku Nagae
Kagerou Imaizumi
Kaguya Houraisan
Kana Anaberal
Kanako Yasaka
Kasen Ibaraki
Keine Kamishirasawa
Kisume
Koakuma
Kogasa Tatara
Koishi Komeiji
Komachi Onozuka
Kosuzu Motoori
Kotohime
Kurumi
Kyouko Kasodani
Letty Whiterock
Lily White
Louise
Luna Child
Lunasa Prismriver
Lyrica Prismriver
Mai
Mamizou Futatsuiwa
Maribel Hearn
Marisa Kirisame
Medicine Melancholy
Meira
Merlin Prismriver
Mima
Minamitsu Murasa
Minoriko Aki
Momiji Inubashiri
Mononobe no Futo
Mugetsu
Mystia Lorelei
Nazrin
Nitori Kawashiro
Nue Houjuu
Orange
Parsee Mizuhashi
Patchouli Knowledge
Raiko Horikawa
Ran Yakumo
Reimu Hakurei
Reisen
Reisen Udongein Inaba
Remilia Scarlet
Renko Usami
Rika
Rikako Asakura
Rin Kaenbyou
Rumia
Sakuya Izayoi
Sanae Kochiya
Sara
Satori Komeiji
Seiga Kaku
Seija Kijin
Sekibanki
Shinki
Shinmyoumaru Sukuna
Shizuha Aki
Shou Toramaru
Soga no Tojiko
Star Sapphire
Suika Ibuki
Sunny Milk
Suwako Moriya
Tenshi Hinanawi
Tewi Inaba
Tokiko
Toyosatomimi no Miko
Utsuho Reiuji
Wakasagihime
Watatsuki no Toyohime
Watatsuki no Yorihime
Wriggle Nightbug
Yamame Kurodani
Yatsuhashi Tsukumo
Yoshika Miyako
Youmu Konpaku
Yukari Yakumo
Yuki
Yumeko
Yumemi Okazaki
Yuugi Hoshiguma
Yuuka Kazami
Yuyuko Saigyouji


There are 111 female characters with distinct personalities and lore in Touhou.
0
TheBookie King of Red
11 years ago
rikku_93 wrote...
I claim Bellows from Suisei no Gargantia(Gargantia on the Verdurous Planet) as my 3rd waifu.


oh you sneaky son of a gun.......
0
Hisobuu
11 years ago
Zandorf wrote...
PumpJack McGee wrote...
-Touhou(Idon'tfuckingknow+)


Just so that you do know in the future, in alphabetical order and female only:
Spoiler:

Alice Margatroid
Aya Shameimaru
Benben Tsukumo
Byakuren Hijiri
Chen
Chiyuri Kitashirakawa
Cirno
Daiyousei
Eiki Shiki, Yamaxanadu
Eirin Yagokoro
Elis
Ellen
Elly
Flandre Scarlet
Fujiwara no Mokou
Gengetsu
Hata no Kokoro
Hatate Himekaidou
Hieda no Akyuu
Hina Kagiyama
Hong Meiling
Ichirin Kumoi
Iku Nagae
Kagerou Imaizumi
Kaguya Houraisan
Kana Anaberal
Kanako Yasaka
Kasen Ibaraki
Keine Kamishirasawa
Kisume
Koakuma
Kogasa Tatara
Koishi Komeiji
Komachi Onozuka
Kosuzu Motoori
Kotohime
Kurumi
Kyouko Kasodani
Letty Whiterock
Lily White
Louise
Luna Child
Lunasa Prismriver
Lyrica Prismriver
Mai
Mamizou Futatsuiwa
Maribel Hearn
Marisa Kirisame
Medicine Melancholy
Meira
Merlin Prismriver
Mima
Minamitsu Murasa
Minoriko Aki
Momiji Inubashiri
Mononobe no Futo
Mugetsu
Mystia Lorelei
Nazrin
Nitori Kawashiro
Nue Houjuu
Orange
Parsee Mizuhashi
Patchouli Knowledge
Raiko Horikawa
Ran Yakumo
Reimu Hakurei
Reisen
Reisen Udongein Inaba
Remilia Scarlet
Renko Usami
Rika
Rikako Asakura
Rin Kaenbyou
Rumia
Sakuya Izayoi
Sanae Kochiya
Sara
Satori Komeiji
Seiga Kaku
Seija Kijin
Sekibanki
Shinki
Shinmyoumaru Sukuna
Shizuha Aki
Shou Toramaru
Soga no Tojiko
Star Sapphire
Suika Ibuki
Sunny Milk
Suwako Moriya
Tenshi Hinanawi
Tewi Inaba
Tokiko
Toyosatomimi no Miko
Utsuho Reiuji
Wakasagihime
Watatsuki no Toyohime
Watatsuki no Yorihime
Wriggle Nightbug
Yamame Kurodani
Yatsuhashi Tsukumo
Yoshika Miyako
Youmu Konpaku
Yukari Yakumo
Yuki
Yumeko
Yumemi Okazaki
Yuugi Hoshiguma
Yuuka Kazami
Yuyuko Saigyouji


There are 111 female characters with distinct personalities and lore in Touhou.


Damn, I would love to see how far we could get with this list alone. I'd contribute.

Limegreen wrote...
Claiming Anjou Naruko from Ano Hi Mita Hana no Namae o Bokutachi wa Mada Shiranai
& Kyou Fujibayashi From Clannad.


Livin' la vida loca :D


I think someone already claimed Kyou a page or two before you.
0
Zaff
11 years ago
Aura-Desu wrote...
Zaff wrote...
I'm actually torn between 3 different girls for the next round, all of which i kinda expected to be taken by now. Seems like theres less people playing this time around.


dammit zaff, I help you out and you steal my waifu e_e

*note to self, never help people again*



Lol sorry, without Yuno I need to get my adorable psychopath fix from somewhere!




On a side note, you guys should claim the rest of the members of the Neighbors Club in Haganai so i get a 6th.
0
waynoinsano
11 years ago
H_I_S_O wrote...

Limegreen wrote...
Claiming Anjou Naruko from Ano Hi Mita Hana no Namae o Bokutachi wa Mada Shiranai
& Kyou Fujibayashi From Clannad.


Livin' la vida loca :D


I think someone already claimed Kyou a page or two before you.


They tried but never said the secret words in either game thread or in discussion so limegreen is good on kyou

A-G since is past games I've always seen her claimed as noel I'm not making any changes unless pumpkin says so
0
Karakasa-chan
11 years ago
So, with those on 5 with more characters for a set what if a single user claims two of the characters?
0
Dee::Arc
11 years ago
Kona-chan wrote...
So, with those on 5 with more characters for a set what if a single user claims two of the characters?


Do you mean can you claim a second waifu in a set if the group is five characters and still get a sixth slot?

A single user can claim half of the group (though I'm not sure how odd numbers round). A single user can have 2 or 3 of the needed claims to form a group of 5, depending on the rounding Jacky decides, but either way, it's still at least 2.
  1. Forums
  3. Incoherent Babbling
Post Reply
Pages 45464748495051