Who would win?

OKEY DOKEY LOL

spoiled them all.. :)

saber my long lost wife are the winner thet vader are an old man perhaps holding that laser sword alredy take the most of him

Seeing as how this fight has no limitations we would have to assume that both are fighting at their full strength. As far as sheer swordplay goes I would have to imagine that Saber and Vader would be equal as far as technique goes but Saber would be able to easily over power Vader. In the movies I don't really remember Vader showing any large amount of physical strength but in Fate Stay Night Saber is able to deflect attacks by Hercules. That in it's self is an amazing feat, not to mention that Saber's attacks are somewhere around 700Mph if I remember right in some battledome match where calculations etc were made (count that as a fact or not if you want, it's a bit hazy, so it's understandable to be doubtful).

Now on to the point of all of this and the main problem that everyone in this thread is arguing over. Saber would have Avalon in her fight with Vader (I lol'd at the thought just now) because she would be at her best. The Avalon we see in Fate Stay Night is the actual original sheath which was recovered by the Einzbern family and given to Kiritsugu, and not one of the Noble Phantasms that came together with the summoning of Saber. She doesn't have a copy because, just like Caliburn, it was already stolen and lost to her.

That's my two cents on the subject as to why Saber would win.

Vader's physical strength has no place in this battle.

*Ignore, accidental post*

[size=10]Fakku wins.[/h]

But you fail.

and can't even run...

seriously in almost every game that I can control vader...HE CAN'T RUN

It's much more gangsta dramatic to walk up to people and choke them.

Saber wins. Dunno if the MK "Fatality" tag can be seen, though.