Tony Taka VS Ishikei: Who does it better? Round 2

Voted for big Tony cause I prefer his art style.

Tony has some great detail and artwork, but Ishikei has great emotions and depth in his, so im gonna have to say Ishikei won my vote.

That was actually a really tough choice. I think I like Tony's work more, but you asked "Who does it better?"

And in my opinion, Ishikei is the best at "what he does." Ishikei's work is, without a doubt, more arousing. And seeing as how these images are made for the purpose of fapping, Ishikei "does it better."

However, Taka is the better artist of the two. But his style is more artistic, and although better drawn, his images just arent as "hot" as Ishikei's.

Simply.

Art: Taka > Ishikei

Hotness: Ishikei > Taka

Ishikei's style is more MOE than Tony !! ISHIKEI !! Ruu...

Tony Taka desu........

Ishikei for me. Tony Taka's girls just seem too...idealistic. Too much of a good thing, maybe.

isn't that what hentai is all about? Drawing the "perfect" woman(s) for us, and then us fappin' to it?

Wow. It's a seesaw battle.

I voted for Tony. Simply because that a negative, for me, is that there's a disconnect with Ishikei's art. Simply put, the anime eyes and hair of the Ishikei girls don't match the fairly realistic structure and skin coloring he uses. Take for example the last frame of the Tsugumi Ishikei sample. The smooth coloring of the skin combined with the structural accuracy of the hands does not match with the large eyes and stiff hair.

So, 2 weeks later and we have a dead tie, 28 votes each. Very nice!

Maybe this could be the next front page poll? Valentine's day has passed so...it'd make sense right?

Agreed... need more voters :smile:
but now Ishikei has take the lead :sad:

I voted Ishikei. Sorry, I can't help it. Compared to his style every other artists drawings looks like scrapings, but the story are not his strong part, I agree whit that.

I voted Ishikei, and I still stand by it, but I just came to own a physical copy of ねこみみばとらあ, and it's pretty amazing.

This is actually a pretty hard decision for me.... if I had to choose... Id say Tony Taka.

* hugs

well , everyone has his/her opinion.. I think this poll appropriate to be on front page.

Always been a fan of Tony Taka... so... yeah.

Tony, cause his character design is good...and I like the genre that he chose...

I like Ishikei art a little more.

Such a hard decision...

Taka's art is a lot more softer and is mostly softcore.

Ishikei's art is a lot more sharper looking and some certain aspects of the body are emphasized

I'm going to have to go with Ishikei with this one....

I've liked a lot more doujins from Ishikei than from Taka >__<