Gundam Vs Macross
what Series would win
0
OKAY. There is no point in arguing this.
Here's the simple layout.
Macross is superior in story as it relates to the audience in a more possible fashion. [Macross > Gundam]
Gundam though is better in other ways. [Zeon > U.N Spacy]
They're both mech anime. One sells albums [Macross] while the other sells plastic models to suckers like me. [Gundam]
No one wins.
If there was a war though it'd be screwed. Macross has missle hell and dimensional rifts while gundam has super hacks pilots. Super hacks pilots doesn't mean they'll win but this also doesn't mean missle spam will save people too. Singing works in a battlefield? As if. But if it does, Gundam SEED singers don't count. They're on par with Mylene. Get real singers and they might have a competition!
Here's the simple layout.
Macross is superior in story as it relates to the audience in a more possible fashion. [Macross > Gundam]
Gundam though is better in other ways. [Zeon > U.N Spacy]
They're both mech anime. One sells albums [Macross] while the other sells plastic models to suckers like me. [Gundam]
No one wins.
If there was a war though it'd be screwed. Macross has missle hell and dimensional rifts while gundam has super hacks pilots. Super hacks pilots doesn't mean they'll win but this also doesn't mean missle spam will save people too. Singing works in a battlefield? As if. But if it does, Gundam SEED singers don't count. They're on par with Mylene. Get real singers and they might have a competition!
0
panservib wrote...
berryl wrote...
2nd, for the most part mobile suits were designed in most of the timelines to have either a very long running fuel life (fusion reactors, or fuel) and of course nearly infinite (nuclear drives). anything from macross had to refuel after a while... so i can give them a little credit against any gundam that needed to be refueled as well (not many comes to mind)
Wait wait, while I am admittedly not a hardcore Gundam fans, I Thought I've seen many example of Gundam in SEED universe Running out of Fuel(Energy) after some battle, when the color turn to gray.
I knew there's some system that developed in SEED universe that allow Gundam to refuel mid-air by means of beam.
Hmmm....I forgot is it installed in ArcAngel or Minerva.............
it is rarely shown on gundam shows they run out of fuel. they mostly run out of ammo, units and mostly lives[pilots and civilians].
0
I wanna vote for macross just because i like it more and its soundtrack is 100% better but, gundam would win in a fight with those stupidly overpowerd giant robots that can single handed wipeout a world
0
I want to say Macross units but the fact that Gundams have a higher magnitude of rape weapons amongst rape weapons amongst Mobile Armors. The argument does lean towards Gundams instead of Macross. But hey I may be wrong, maybe a fell sweep with several Macross canons would crush the Gundam forces depending on UC or otherwise.
0
mwong04 wrote...
I want to say Macross units but the fact that Gundams have a higher magnitude of rape weapons amongst rape weapons amongst Mobile Armors. The argument does lean towards Gundams instead of Macross. But hey I may be wrong, maybe a fell sweep with several Macross canons would crush the Gundam forces depending on UC or otherwise.Gundam X units will cover for the macross cannons... DX + X + bunch of GX-bits + we will let Zero custom join! Now im remembering my units at SD Gundam GGen World
In my opinion Macross prioritizes mobility than weapon unlike Gundams who uses rape weapon then customizes it even further... still Nekki Basara will still kick ass in the battlefield using music...
its not that hard to choose between my 2 childhood animes.... I still have my uncle's Macross:SDF vhs
