Awesome your stepping up your game. This is getting fun (No I'm not being sarcastic, I'm actually having fun).
Varuna wrote...
Pointing out the reason saying it would protect the prostitutes from others is a very reasonable thought. Everyone wants to remain safe, but what is keeping people safe from STDs? I'm not paranoid, but look at alcohol for an example. The rules are for people not to drink and drive. Simple as that, people still do it anyway. Do you honestly think people are going to follow the rules and have their STD tests monthly?
The tests at the nevada brothels are weekly not monthly. If their girls don't get a test they are required to stop prostitution until they get a test. If they test positive then the company is mandated to contact all the people who have had sex with that prostitute since her last exam. Not to mention that the girls are required to examine the client, and use condoms along with other measures.
Varuna wrote...
It's very ironic when people say this has nothing to do with morals. Having morals is what keeps you in line with the law. If you had no morals, you wouldn't obey the law in the first place. You'd be breaking laws left and right because you have no morals. Concept applies to prostitution as well. Do you honestly think prostitutes will stop having sex just because they tested positive with STDs? Give me a break.
My position is that this isn't a moral issue. If you don't agree with prostitution then don't become one, or visit one. I stay within the law because I don't want to get punished. I don't speed in traffic because I'll get a ticket, which raises my car insurance. Also my economy car would crumple like an empty beer car in an accident. You appear to be confusing me and others with being Nihilist.
The company would be held liable for a extremely large penalty. The women have no privacy when it comes to STD screens. If they test positive the company is notified immediately and she will be moved somewhere else such as office work or terminated entirely unless the STD can be cured to which afterward she may be allowed to work again.
If you know about STDs, symptoms vary greatly. Some don't show signs of STDs at all until a few years later. STD check ups aren't very accurate.
This is why condoms are used.
According to a 2004 bulletin from the World Health Organization and a 2001 report by the National Institutes of Health, individual studies found condom use reduced the risk of infection for:
# Genital herpes, by 30 percent to 92 percent in women; less in men (no number given).
# Gonorrhea, by 49 percent to 75 percent in men, and by 39 percent to 62 percent in women.
# Chlamydia, by 26 percent to 90 percent in women and by 33 percent in men.
# Pelvic inflammatory disease, by 55 percent. PID is a leading cause of infertility and is caused by gonorrhea and chlamydia infection.
# Trichomoniasis, by 30 percent in women, with significant reduction in men (no number given).
# Syphilis, by 40 percent to 60 percent in both sexes.
# Genital ulcers (chancroid), by 18 percent to 23 percent.
Though should be about enough to persuade anybody on how effective condoms are alone and not in combination with other safety measures.
The brothels of Nevada are even safer than porn sites
[/quote]
Non scientific Link
This isn't drugs, this isn't like watching porn, which can't be contracted. This is diseases contracting around since legalizing prostitution would bring in more customers thus having a larger scale and risk of spreading STDs. Some little STD check ups aren't going to prevent it. STD tests just tell people that they have STDs, it doesn't cure it.
Even if the system isn't perfect, legalizing it is better than the status quo. People will still pay to have sex. That is a fact that will never go away. Prostitutes will always be around, no matter how strict the laws or severe the punishment. At least legalizing it will reduce the risk of disease if not eliminate it. Free women from physical and psychological abuse at the hands of pimps and abusing clients. Remove the drug addicts and other undesirables from the industry. Then on top of all of that, you can collect tax money from the industry which would help everybody from school funding, welfare programs.
Out of curiosity, where did you get the statistics that you posted? You didn't put up any citation so I couldn't read it for myself.