[Anime] Fate/Stay Night Remake By Ufotable

0
mibuchiha Fakku Elder
I certainly don't remember much of the fight moves existing in VN but hell this is the kind of deviations I approve of.

Ignoring the plot and some characters, this is without a doubt watchable.
0
Spoiler:
Forum Image: http://puu.sh/czbAb/f24f11bd71.jpg
THIS ISN'T HER ROUTE


Saber casual clothes are nice. Saber smiles more than I remember in the VN. Illya monologue was okay, this isn't Heaven's Feel but I can see why Ufotable want to establish that part of her for the upcoming movie.
0
WideEyedMan wrote...
Spoiler:
Forum Image: http://puu.sh/czbAb/f24f11bd71.jpg
THIS ISN'T HER ROUTE


Saber casual clothes are nice. Saber smiles more than I remember in the VN. Illya monologue was okay, this isn't Heaven's Feel but I can see why Ufotable want to establish that part of her for the upcoming movie.


Not only for that, but mainly because ufotable needs to establish at least a bit of characterization for her to compensate for the missing Fate route.
I think that's the main reason why we get these additional scenes that weren't in the original UBW. Since they can't expect every viewer to go play the Fate route or watch the 2006 anime, they need to adjust their script so that everything remains cohesive even without the Fate route. It also serves as a nice way to change POVs once in a while, a bit like how Fate/Zero handled that, but without revealing any relevant information until the MCs find out for themselves.

I'm most curious about how they plan to handle Saber's non-existent closure in this route. Also did the VN actually reveal the blonde person's identity in a meaningful way in the UBW route? I can't really remember.
0
mibuchiha wrote...
I certainly don't remember much of the fight moves existing in VN but hell this is the kind of deviations I approve of.

Ignoring the plot and some characters, this is without a doubt watchable.


For the most part all of them exist.

Hrunting : Hound of the Red Plains
Strike Air : Hammer of the Wind King
Caladbolg II : Fake Helix Sword

What was deviated from the show though was how Strike Air was used and the entire use Caladbolg II.
It's been a while since I played the VN but he only used Caladbolg II vs
Spoiler:
Caster


But in this he basically spammed Hrunting. Also, I'm a little confused by how Saber
Spoiler:
killed Berserker once


Strike Air is a C-rank Noble Phantasm, and Berserker's rejects anything that's not GREATER than A-Rank.

Spoiler:
The only way I can see it go down is that for a brief moment, Saber released Strike Air revealing her true blade, and wounded him, and killed him with the blast of Strike Air before re-veiling her blade.

Not that I'm complaining at all, this is still easily the best produced anime I've seen in production value since Redline and that's pretty bias from me since that was entirely hand-drawn.

Anyways, Episode 4
I was expecting to see even the smallest amount of quality loss in the production values. Guess it's not happening with Ufotable doing this. Another great episode, some detours here and there, but this is definitely catered to those who watched F/Z. But to the readers of the VN, you can smile a bit at how well developed the characters are becoming, and those winter attires.
0
Cyndas wrote...


Spoiler:
In the VN he used Caladbolg II against Berserker in the graveyard, although he was the only one aware of it's existence at the time. I'm not sure if he used Caladbolg II against Caster in this one.

Yes Saber did not kill Berserker in the cemetery in the VN.



TheJ4cK wrote...
I'm most curious about how they plan to handle Saber's non-existent closure in this route. Also did the VN actually reveal the blonde person's identity in a meaningful way in the UBW route? I can't really remember.


Spoiler:
Pretty much Saber realized that the fights were getting serious enough near the end game,somewhere around where Rin becomes Saber's master, she reveals her true name and Noble Phantasm Exacalibur to Rin and Emiya while planning to assault Ryudou Temple. It's pretty anti-climatic but this route is one where Saber has the most diminished role.

Also I'm hoping there is a Ufotable Fate remake, simply put there is too much information in that route to condense or leave hanging in the other routes. Although I'm wondering if they are using Fate/Zero to supplement.
0
WideEyedMan wrote...
Cyndas wrote...


Spoiler:
In the VN he used Caladbolg II against Berserker in the graveyard, although he was the only one aware of it's existence at the time. I'm not sure if he used Caladbolg II against Caster in this one.

Yes Saber did not kill Berserker in the cemetery in the VN.






Spoiler:
I'm actually super aware that Saber didn't kill Berserker during their first meet, but the thing that confused me was how she actually killed him using Strike Air, unless she used like some Excali-beam.

Cyndas wrote...

Strike Air is a C-rank Noble Phantasm, and Berserker's rejects anything that's not GREATER than A-Rank. The only way I can see it go down is that for a brief moment, Saber released Strike Air revealing her true blade, and wounded him, and killed him with the blast of Strike Air before re-veiling her blade.



I mean I guess it kind makes sense, she broke the veil on her blade, and stabbed him and blasted him while he was vulnerable with Strike Air maybe? I mean, I'm not complaining, that looked sick as shit. It's just a minor inconsistency with Berserker's NP

Edit: I just watched it again, I'm fucking stupid because that's exactly what happened.



I worded it a bit poorly with my bad formatting so that may have led to that confusion.

Edit: I just watched it again, I'm fucking stupid because that's exactly what happened.
0
WideEyedMan wrote...

Spoiler:
Pretty much Saber realized that the fights were getting serious enough near the end game,somewhere around where Rin becomes Saber's master, she reveals her true name and Noble Phantasm Exacalibur to Rin and Emiya while planning to assault Ryudou Temple. It's pretty anti-climatic but this route is one where Saber has the most diminished role.

Also I'm hoping there is a Ufotable Fate remake, simply put there is too much information in that route to condense or leave hanging in the other routes. Although I'm wondering if they are using Fate/Zero to supplement.


Spoiler:
I figured as much. But even with Fate/Zero as supplementary material, Saber wouldn't get any meaningful closure - or even development for that matter - in this route. I think it would only piss off the Fate/Zero-only watchers immensely, if they decided to strictly stick to UBWs stroyline.
Luckily though, it seems that they try to deviate a bit from the original UBW script to make room for Saber and Ilya (and to a lesser extend Kirei and Blondie) to compensate for the non-existing Fate adaptation. This of course also nicely acts as a connection to Fate/Zero. I find it really funny how coincidental that is.


Here's what I hope they'll do later down the line.
Spoiler:
Just before they assault Ryudou temple (before Shirou gets a mana transfer from Rin), just stick Saber's "confession" in here about her past war experience with Kiritsugu and how she is actually not dead, explaining her circumstances.
This could work pretty well, seeing as how closely Fate and UBW can be connected in terms of structure(with Fate laying out the groundwork and UBW expanding on it). But even then, how are they going to make her come in terms with her past in this route without focusing too much on her??
Also, hopefully she at least shouts out her NP's name before she goes off, because I can't remember she actually did that in the VN.
0
TheJ4cK wrote...
Also, hopefully she at least shouts out her NP's name before she goes off, because I can't remember she actually did that in the VN.[/spoil]


She did
0
It's okay Rin, we all know you missed your shots on purpose.

Also, Ufotable knows how to capture Rider's deadly charm.

Spoiler:
Forum Image: http://31.media.tumblr.com/2aca69174b8303a4cf6c179cbb13fd40/tumblr_ner2df6raV1rrr564o1_500.gif


WideEyedMan wrote...
Spoiler:
Forum Image: http://puu.sh/czbAb/f24f11bd71.jpg
THIS ISN'T HER ROUTE



It hurts.
0
God damn it ... so it turns out that last week's preview of this week's episode was just a gigantic cock tease because the end of this episode is ... a gigantic cock tease.
I wanna see ufotable's take on
Spoiler:
TSUBAME GAESHI
so badly
0
... Suddenly I really want to watch F/SN in movie style. While the other 2 routes are more entertaining than Fate route, it was also the most innocent and happy one out of them all. A summer dream seems to describe it perfectly.
0
Zolnir wrote...
... Suddenly I really want to watch F/SN in movie style.


I think a movie or OVA type would be the most likely. Another 24 episodes series would just be redundant unless it happens in 8 years.

most innocent and happy one out of them all


most happy one out of them all


most happy


ಠ_ಠ

Spoiler:

Most heartbreaking shit I've ever witnessed in my whole anime life bar none.

Forum Image: http://80.86.95.2:3083/h/3456532e51cc2e1e4da88181bb0a1fb859d33037-206192-800-600-jpg/keystamp=1416137100-b90c1408af/A40b.jpg

Forum Image: http://198.50.206.128:2001/h/cba6eeb09f2a49ff5552677e59e2187ee080c659-304759-800-600-jpg/keystamp=1416136500-da48cc2043/A42.jpg

0
mibuchiha Fakku Elder
Saber sleeps bottomless. Suddenly this crappy plot doesn't bug me as much anymore.

Would have been perfect if she also undoes her hair.
0
Hentanize wrote...

Most heartbreaking shit I've ever witnessed in my whole anime life bar none.


http://www.animenewsnetwork.com/news/2014-09-10/fate-kaleid-liner-prisma-illya-gets-tv-anime-sequel-in-2015/.78614

Also your pics aren't showing.

Meanwhile Archer is second tsundere in the UBW route.
0
Eh, depends on your definition I guess. As a person she died happy with the troubles plaguing her since she became a King finally resolved, and she no longer once to erase her very existence in an attempt of self-sacrifice that seems shittier than Archer's. That's a better death than most people would have, for sure.
0
Aww shit! The fabled Monohoshi Zao! I've always loved Kojirou Assassin since Fate Unlimited Codes the game because he was broke as fuck. Then I saw Carnival Phantasm's Grand Prix.
Spoiler:
Forum Image: http://i.imgur.com/LKoLdhL.png
Forum Image: http://i.imgur.com/vo1R3FZ.png


I was DYING.
0
Zolnir wrote...
Eh, depends on your definition I guess. As a person she died happy with the troubles plaguing her since she became a King finally resolved, and she no longer once to erase her very existence in an attempt of self-sacrifice that seems shittier than Archer's. That's a better death than most people would have, for sure.


Spoiler:
She still wants to sacrifice herself(simply in a different manner) and her troubles as a King are inherently unresolved since the legend will always end the same way, she's just accepted the fact that her kingdom's done for, her life in Fuyuki is equally irreplaceable as her life as King Arthur(as damning as that is) and her atonement for that will be through the Throne of Heroes. It's why I'm iffish about the True Ending for Fate, since Arturia gets away with Shirou after the ending established that her destiny was to be eternally seated at the Throne of Heroes.


Cyndas wrote...
I was DYING.


Spoiler:
Forum Image: https://38.media.tumblr.com/779908b23605dc144e5dcb140ed22eda/tumblr_n3790oBbWJ1rrr564o1_500.gif
Carnival Phantasm is so perfect.
0
from 1 to 10 how worth is the remake worth watching? o0o
0
Kaimax Best Master-San
xhimitsu wrote...
from 1 to 10 how worth is the remake worth watching? o0o


EX/10

See and judge it yourself
0
Hiken...
Spoiler:
[size=28]TSUBAME GAESHI[/h]
Forum Image: http://puu.sh/d1vg2/5f63ea91b5.jpg


...

Forum Image: https://33.media.tumblr.com/ecdcc35ca406e13b2279ff285a1d399b/tumblr_nfggi8GU251qa94xto1_500.gif