Mahou Shoujo Madoka Magica

#2 really sounds like dimension traveling, even though it's made clear that she's time traveling. to support this theory, in each time she goes back, all the people around her has a "probability" to change also. that's why everything is different everytime. each individuals are not "bound" by the a time loop.

So after racking my brain for the past 2 hours over this, I have found a plot hole [I think...]. In Timeline 3, Sayaka and Kyoko are Mahou Shoujo, right? If this is true, then where were they during Timeline 1's Walpurgis Night? They are also nowhere to be found in Timeline 2 or 4.

That was epic shit right there reminds me of a song "Time Warp" but I won't get into that who expected this to happen wow Homura looked really cute before she became Mahou and all such an awesome power also to stop time and have a hidden pocket that's some powerful stuff also do you think it's just a huge time paradox or is it lol I think I see the ending but I will shut up cause who knows what might happen

Why SAyaka and Kyoko are not in timeline 2 or 4:
1. Sayaka didn't need to wish for her childhood friend
2. There's a possibility that Kyoko, was never made into a Mahou shoujo

There's unlimited possibilities
-there's also a possibility that it was "never shown" in the anime.

Easiest way to solve this is to kill Madoka..
Because Homura cannot beat the withc in Walpurgis Night, and then Madoka will make a contract just because she wants to help homura.

lol

they need to find someway to beat the Witch of Walpurgis Night without making MAdoka change.

it can save people from death and fixed permanently broken bones

erase QB and/or permanently end Walpugis Night? or hell even wish for all mahou shoujo's lives to be returned back to normal

wish for a soul gem that can never turn into a grief seed

If you kill Madoka (wtf am I saying), the Walpurgis Witch will still appear, and Homura will either also turn into a witch or die from battling it and nothing will be solved, other than QB's search for energy. The question is, what happens to this witch if there's nobody to stop it? Does it continue to rage on other planets? If QB is using that dograbbit body as a shell, does he have a type of soul gem-like thingy too? I still think the entropy thing is BS. /random_rant

QB = Legion

he doesn't need a Soul gem, since he will always have another spare waiting when the curret one dies.

and I think Soul gems only apply to the mahou shoujo.

How to beat the witch:
Homura needs to get some ICBM... rofl

That defeats the purpose of time. Sayaka uses her wish to heal Kyosuke's hand, and Kyoko uses her wish to make people join her father's religion. Homura doesn't have the power to change those events. Kyosuke still breaks his hand and Kyoko's father still invents his religion. I guess we can argue "The Butterfly Effect", in which one little thing that happens can drastically alter the timeline. After reviewing the episode again, and seeing the calendar, the amount of time between the hospital and meeting Madoka is 9 days, assuming of course that the pink flower [the 16th] symbolizes Homura leaving the hospital, the "beginning of time", and that the blue stars [the 25th] symbolizes her first day of school, in which she meets Madoka. Anything that happened before the 16th cannot be altered, so Kyoko should be a Mahou Shoujo seeing as how she was rather young when she made her wish. Another thing that shouldn't be altered is how Kyosuke broke his hand, but we don't know if this happens before or after the 16th, and thus is susceptible to "The Butterfly Effect". The question remains, what happens during those 9 days that causes the changes in the Timelines, aside from the obvious changes?

-Sayaka never met with QB.
-Kyoko never went into their district to meet up with them

The fact is MAmi/Madoka/Homura never met with "Sayaka the mahou shoujou", because you saw yourself in timeline 3 that Mami will freak out when she knows that they can turn into a witch and started killing each other, and that never happened in the 1st and 2nd timeline.

in the 4th, we can assume that it's the same event that has already happened with the 5th because everyone that is not seen probably died the same way in the 5th.

Homura will indeed be fighting the Walpurgis Night and will probably do some damage. However, she will choice off guard at some point where Madoka will come to her side where she will remember her past where she gain her powers back and team up with Homura to finish the fight (Sorry for the Halo quote XD). Afterwards is up in the air as anything, good or bad, will happen.

I wouldn't mind/be surprised if this goes on longer, like Higurashi(by that I mean make 2 seasons), just have Madoka become a Puella Magi-die and Homura repeat again, and make a second season. Pretty much, piss us off and make us viewers wait for a second season.